The Industry's Leading Source For F&I, Sales And Technology

Article

Examining the CFPB’s Arbitration Rule

Legal experts break down the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s new arbitration rule and how it could affect your dealership.

August 2017, F&I and Showroom - Feature

by Thomas B. Hudson, Esq. - Also by this author

On July 10, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau announced a new arbitration rule banning companies (called “providers” in the rule) from using pre-dispute arbitration agreements to prohibit consumers from seeking class relief in a court. The new rule follows two CFPB “studies” that were transparent attempts to justify what the bureau’s staffers were determined to do all along — end the use of arbitration agreements in consumer financial transactions.

In the Dodd-Frank Act, Congress instructed the bureau to study the use of arbitration provisions in consumer financial contracts and to take action based on those studies, including anything from regulation of the provisions to an outright ban on them.

Lawyers are still wrestling with the 700-plus page rule and considering issues such as whether the rule permits the financing of a vehicle service contract — sold in both cash and credit transactions — containing an arbitration agreement barring class relief. 

We don’t know what the bureau was thinking when developing the rule, but it’s likely it was aware that dealers and finance companies would be reluctant to use an arbitration agreement that permitted class relief. It’s also likely the bureau did not want to risk the political backlash an outright ban on the use of mandatory pre-dispute arbitration agreements (otherwise permitted by the Federal Arbitration Act) might entail. So, wielding a scalpel rather than a chainsaw, the bureau came up with a rule that permitted mandatory, pre-dispute arbitration for individual cases, but also permitted class actions in court.

As an added deterrent from using arbitration, the bureau has mandated onerous reporting requirements for companies invoking arbitration. The requirements, which direct regular redacted submissions to the bureau of arbitration and court documents, will likely be an operational nightmare for companies.

Why do car dealers care about the new rule? Because, beginning in the ’90s, dealers and the finance companies that buy retail installment sales agreements and leases from them began to incorporate mandatory arbitration agreements into their credit sale and leasing transactions.

They did so primarily because a well-drafted and consumer-friendly arbitration agreement provided a very strong first line of defense against class action lawsuits. The principal strength of arbitration agreements was language prohibiting the consumer from seeking class relief.

Plaintiffs’ lawyers suing businesses such as car dealerships often attempt to leverage the settlement value of their clients’ individual cases by asserting or attempting to assert claims on behalf of the individual and others who are “similarly situated” — magic legal words that mean, “this is a class action.”

The rule’s impact will vary depending on the identity of the dealer or creditor involved and the facts of the transactions at hand. Dealers exempt from the bureau’s jurisdiction under Dodd-Frank will be affected indirectly by the rule, while nonexempt dealers will be impacted directly. Lawyers are still wrestling with the 700-plus page rule and considering issues such as whether the rule permits the financing of a vehicle service contract — sold in both cash and credit transactions — containing an arbitration agreement barring class relief. Suffice it to say, if your sale, finance or lease documents contain an arbitration agreement of any sort, you need to engage your lawyer.

We were predicting, pre-Trump, that the use of arbitration agreements in auto finance and lease transactions would be prohibited by the bureau. Then along came Trump, and, at about the same time, a federal court opinion, since appealed, that the bureau’s structure was unconstitutional. Then came a Trump-issued executive order that might or might not apply to an “independent agency” like the bureau, freezing new federal rules.

These developments gave the industry some real hope that the bureau would not make waves by issuing this rule. Perhaps CFPB Director Richard Cordray, whose term expires in July 2018, eyed the general health care and Russian meddling messes in Washington, figured Congress was scheduled to go home for the summer, and decided it was “now or never.”

The rule was published in the Federal Register on July 19, 2017. It provides that all pre-dispute arbitration agreements entered into on or after the 241st day after the publication of the rule in the Federal Register must comply with the rule. Its effective date is the 60th day after publication in the Federal Register, or Sept. 18, 2017. The compliance date is March 19, 2018.

Some are predicting Congress will overturn the rule by using its power under the Congressional Review Act or by an even more obscure process with the Federal Stability Oversight Council. Others are predicting a new director and possible delays in the compliance date. Still others are predicting legal actions. We think all of these defenses are far from sure bets and dealers and finance sources should be prepared for compliance with the rule come March.

Thomas B. Hudson and Nicole F. Munro are partners in the law firm of Hudson Cook LLP. Email them at tom.hudson@bobit.com or nikki.munro@bobit.com. Copyright CounselorLibrary.com 2017, all rights reserved. Single publication rights only, to F&I and Showroom. (7/17). HC No. 4811-2926-4459

Comment

  1. 1. Barry Leman [ August 29, 2017 @ 09:33AM ]

    This is why it is extremely important for Trump to dump all Obama appointees. Cordray is attempting to make business as difficult as possible, while lining the pockets of attorneys.

  2. 2. Barry Leman [ August 29, 2017 @ 09:33AM ]

    This is why it is extremely important for Trump to dump all Obama appointees. Cordray is attempting to make business as difficult as possible, while lining the pockets of attorneys.

 

Your Comment

Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:
Your Name:  
Your Email:  

Blog

So Here's the Deal

Ronald J. Reahard
Selling High-Mileage VSC Plans

By Ronald J. Reahard
How do you sell a $3,000 VSC on an $8,000 car? Top trainer offers a four-step process to ensure every customer gets the protection they need.

Selling Warranty Compliance Plans

By Ronald J. Reahard
Do-it-yourself customers will tell you they prefer to save a few bucks by performing their own maintenance. F&I trainer has the perfect response for this common objection.

Handling the ‘Last Car’ Objection

By Ronald J. Reahard

Sold But Not Closed

By Ronald J. Reahard

Done Deal

Gregory Arroyo
Rescinding the CFPB’s Auto Finance Guidance

By Gregory Arroyo
The editor debunks a few myths about the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, then explains why the industry is on the brink of repealing the bureau’s auto finance guidance.

Still a Work in Progress

By Gregory Arroyo
The editor explains why he put another digital retailing startup on the cover and looks at two studies that point to online car buying and financing still being a work in progress.

It Is Unwise to Lower Your Defenses

By Gregory Arroyo

What's Really Behind the Subprime Pullback?

By Gregory Arroyo

Mad Marv

Marv Eleazer
Your F&I Backup Plan

By Marv Eleazer
Equipment failures can’t stop an F&I manager who is prepared for any contingency. His Madness lists four backup plans you can implement today.

Love It or Leave It

By Marv Eleazer
His Madness is reminded that excelling at F&I requires true passion for the craft. He offers a few suggestions for staying focused and mentally sharp.

G.O.Y.A.

By Marv Eleazer

The Little Things

By Marv Eleazer

On the Point

Jim Ziegler
Sharpen Your Survival Skills

By Jim Ziegler
‘Da Man’ has a plan you can use to survive the collapse of the car business and remain profitable through the dealer apocalypse.

Sales Rock Stars Still Exist

By Jim Ziegler
Da Man says $40,000-a-month sales rock stars still exist. He says you’ll find them on YouTube and Facebook Live.

The New Stooges

By Jim Ziegler

Is Your Quick Lube Driving Away Business?

By Jim Ziegler