The Industry's Leading Source For F&I, Sales And Technology


Menu Reboot

November 2012, F&I and Showroom - Feature

by Gregory Arroyo - Also by this author

Tom Wilson, dealership development manager for American Financial and Automotive Services, said interest in the mobile menu was low among the 100 dealers he surveyed in his mountain states region.
Tom Wilson, dealership development manager for American Financial and Automotive Services, said interest in the mobile menu was low among the 100 dealers he surveyed in his mountain states region.

One could say the organizers of Industry Summit 2012 saved the best for last. On the final day of the Industry Summit, five mobile menu execs and an award-winning F&I director-turned-trainer gathered for “F&I Unplugged: Debating the Mobile Menu.” 

The show program tabbed it as a debate, and the panel didn’t disappoint. If it were a focus group, software makers would have learned they have a ways to go to convince nonbelievers that the tablet menu is a natural evolution of F&I’s key selling tool.

Opponents in the audience, such as Alex Robinson, an F&I professional with Pueblo, Colo.-based Solon Auto Group, made clear they’re not interested without proof that it won’t put their jobs at risk.

“As a finance director, I have three responsibilities, which are time, profit and compliance,” Robinson said. “I want to know who you’re bouncing the compliance issues, the time issue and the profit issue off of.”

Kelly Wadlinger of Faulkner FIAT of Harrisburg, Pa., was even more direct. “Is there hard data showing customers are pushing for this?” she asked. “Or is this really the industry trying to push it onto us because it’s another moneymaker?”

The two-hour, two-session discussion began with five software makers taking 10 minutes apiece to demonstrate their tablet offerings. First up was OptionSoft’s Nick Sennett, followed by MaximTrak’s Jim Maxim, Jr., then Innovative Aftermarket Systems (IAS)’ Matt Nowicki, The Impact Group’s Mark Thorpe and iTapMenu’s Shawn McCool.

Solutions varied by design and approach, but the five software makers maintained that consumer acceptance of mobile devices, particularly the tablet, is what’s driving them to unplug the F&I menu. Maxim said vehicle manufacturers also are on board, noting that Nissan is extremely interested in mobile technologies. Adoption isn’t high right now, but he believes that will change in the years to come.

“We see 90 percent [of dealers] not being ready, while 10 percent want it,” he said. “Our company’s position is not to push a specific technology. But if a dealer wants it, we want to make sure it’s ready to roll.”

Matt Nowicki, vice president of retail software for IAS, talks about the company’s new SmartMenu Interactive.
Matt Nowicki, vice president of retail software for IAS, talks about the company’s new SmartMenu Interactive.

IAS’ Nowicki — who used the session to unveil SmartMenu Interactive, his company’s new tablet menu software — and OptionSoft’s Sennett described the similar paths their companies took to arrive at the mobile menu. The execs said their companies’ initial interest in the tablet was to create a tool that could adapt to current dealer processes, which is why their entrance into the category centered on a survey tool to automate the customer interview.

But Nowicki said the menu is due for an update, which is what the tablet menu represents. “When the menu was first introduced, it corrected a serious problem with step selling in the industry, and that’s still the case today,” he explained. “… And that’s why this is more of an evolution and not a real shift. Nobody up here is changing the way the menu process works. We’re just presenting it in a different manner.”

iTapMenu’s McCool, a former agent with 15 years in the car business, said his invention was meant to correct design flaws in current menu offerings, specifically the four-column structure that most current solutions offer.

Not all panelists seemed convinced the tablet is the next step. The Impact Group’s Thorpe, who demonstrated the company’s Fusion menu, said his company is preparing to release the next version of its interactive menu in early 2013. He added that he’s not sure tablets will be part of his software’s next generation.

“We’ve spent the last year in design meetings thinking in terms of what the capabilities are, how [the tablet] can be used more effectively to move the ball down the field,” he said. “But what I don’t want to do in the process of doing that is take any chance of unwinding 50 years’ worth of best practices.”

The Hybrid Effect

Joining the panel for its second hour was Tom Wilson, dealership development manager for American Financial and Automotive Services’ mountain states region. The former F&I Dealer of the Year made clear he’s not convinced the tablet is the next step in the menu’s evolution, but he let a 100-dealer survey he conducted do the talking.

“Virtually all the dealers I surveyed [said] they don’t even know what it is,” he said. “What dealers are saying is, ‘Show me, prove to me that it works.’ The other issue is they’re process-driven and they’re very comfortable with their processes. So the iPad has to come with instructions.”

McCool invited audience members to view user testimonials posted on his company’s website. He added that his company spends more time training users on process and workflow than demonstrating his tool’s features. “We’re very specific on our approach, and that is to get the deal, make the menu, go out to the customer before buyer’s remorse sets in, make the presentation there, come back in, update your DMS, print off your docs and then bring the customer into F&I for the first time,” he said.

Tom Wilson says the key to the tablet menu taking hold is the process developers build around it.
Tom Wilson says the key to the tablet menu taking hold is the process developers build around it.

Wilson then questioned the timing of the mobile menu. He said dealers in his region are still recovering from the Great Recession, adding that they are more interested in getting employees trained and their processes dialed in than investing in unproven technology. Those who are, he noted, tend to be highline dealers who view the mobile menu as a chance to move to the hybrid manager concept, where the roles of sales and F&I are combined. That statement set the debate in ­motion.

Tony Dupaquier, AFAS’ director of F&I training, stepped up to the microphone. Earlier that day, he had moderated a panel focused on the hybrid manager concept. He told panelists that none of the participants in his session have been able to make it work consistently.

“Not a soul is seeing one dealership working effectively by utilizing this term, ‘hybrid manager,’” Dupaquier said. “And what I wondered is, where did this come from? It’s coming from this panel right here.”

Panelists jumped to respond, with Nowicki taking the lead. He said his company works with a dealer group in the South that employs the hybrid manager, but said that operation isn’t doing it with electronic menus; it’s doing it with paper.

“None of us advocate hybrid managers,” he said. “The reason that comes up is people assume that when you say mobile menu, that means it’s going to be used in that type of situation. I think everyone here disagrees with that 100 percent.”

The talk of the hybrid manager baffled Zurich Financial Services’ Glenn Roberts. The business development manager said his company surveyed about 800 dealers between 2010 and 2011 to find out if the downturn had raised interest in combining sales and F&I duties.

The response was low, Roberts said, but he didn’t discount the belief that the tablet menu could drive up interest. That’s why he said menu makers need to define the mobile menu’s purpose.

“The question everyone’s interested in is, what exactly is the value of the technology?” he said. “We’re interested in the technology, too. And we’ve been talking to some of you guys, but we’ve not been able to isolate what the effect is.”

Your Comment

Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:
Your Name:  
Your Email:  


So Here's the Deal

Ronald J. Reahard
Menus Don’t Work Miracles

By Ronald J. Reahard
A fancy new menu can help streamline processes and improve customer engagement, but it won’t replace the hard-won skill and compassion of a true F&I professional.

Avoiding the AAA Objection

By Ronald J. Reahard
Top trainer advises F&I pros to eliminate the ‘I have AAA’ objection by downplaying the very real — but relatively minor — roadside assistance benefit included with most service contracts.

(Video) Capture Missed VSC Sales

By Ronald J. Reahard

The Dealer Moved My Goal Posts

By Ronald J. Reahard

Done Deal

Gregory Arroyo
Car Buyers Need F&I

By Gregory Arroyo
Current market trends are playing right into the F&I product pitch, but they also reveal trouble ahead for the automotive retail industry at large.

Protecting F&I’s Future

By Gregory Arroyo
The editor responds to a reader’s question about whether F&I managers are being replaced by iPads and digital retailing tools.

Game Almost Over

By Gregory Arroyo

The Repair Is Covered

By Gregory Arroyo

Mad Marv

Marv Eleazer
'We Never Buy This Stuff'

By Marv Eleazer
Every F&I pro gets the occasional ‘F’ customer, but they’re a small part of your business and they’re not worth a minute of mental anguish.

Stop Painting Dealers With a Broad Brush

By Marv Eleazer
His Madness has a few choice words for media members who obsess over every act of dealer malfeasance while ignoring their charitable and volunteer efforts.

I Love F&I. How About You?

By Marv Eleazer

Is That Legal?

By Marv Eleazer

On the Point

Jim Ziegler
Bound to Fail

By Jim Ziegler
Da Man returns with a message to vehicle manufacturers jumping into the subscription waters: It ain’t gonna happen.

Sharpen Your Survival Skills

By Jim Ziegler
‘Da Man’ has a plan you can use to survive the collapse of the car business and remain profitable through the dealer apocalypse.

Sales Rock Stars Still Exist

By Jim Ziegler

The New Stooges

By Jim Ziegler