The Industry's Leading Source For F&I, Sales And Technology


Setting Up the Edesk

Continuing with his noble effort to define the edealership, the magazine’s resident compliance pro explains why the desking process is ripe for digitization.

August 2017, F&I and Showroom - Feature

by Gil Van Over - Also by this author

As the industry is moving, in varying degrees, from manual processes to digital processes, the desking process is one process that is ripe for digitization — perhaps even at the top of the list of the processes that should be converted.

We have a few working theories in our consulting practice. These working theories help us to focus on probable areas of concern as we begin reviewing deal files. One working theory is that if a dealership is still buying Sharpies to complete paper four-squares, we will probably find a higher percentage of packed payments or potentially discriminatory pricing — that’s if we can fully decipher the scrawl and figure out whether the green Sharpie is the first pencil or the final agreement.

It can be difficult to detect some of these methods with a colorful, confusing four-square. Maybe that’s why some sales managers or general sales managers insist on keeping their paper forms and buying Sharpies.

At the least, we usually find that there is not a consistent approach to quoting the first pencil.

There are two primary sales processes in the industry today: Some dealers will not quote payments during the sales process and focus on negotiating the trade difference before “TO’ing” the customer to F&I. Other dealers employ a process where the focus is on the payment from very early in the sales process. Some dealers use a combination of the two.
For dealerships that quote payments as part of the sales process, there are many compliance pitfalls a dealer must guard against. Working the trade difference is not as susceptible to compliance issues — after all, if you don’t quote a payment, you can’t pack a payment.

The first potential compliance issue with quoting payments is an expectation from the Dark Side that the payment quote is accurate for what is disclosed and contemplated at that point in the negotiation. One contingent of the Dark Side, the attorneys general, coined the phrase “payment packing” around 30 years ago and considers it a deceptive practice.

Payment packing can take many forms, such as including undisclosed F&I products in the payment quote, using an undisclosed short term to artificially increase the payment, using a rate that is higher than the known rate if an approval has already been obtained, extending the number of days to first payment, or shortening the number of payments per year. Of course, the old-school, ubiquitous “leg” is packing a payment.

It can be difficult to detect some of these methods with a colorful, confusing four-square. Maybe that’s why some sales managers or general sales managers insist on keeping their paper forms and buying Sharpies.

Another problematic issue with quoting payments can be perceived discriminatory pricing. If I conducted an analysis of the first pencils during a period of time, and the results show that any of the protected classes under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act were quoted higher rates than the rest of the deals, an allegation of discriminatory pricing could be leveled.

Many dealers who quote payments during the sales process have implemented a policy on how first pencil payments are to be quoted. Essentially, it depends on whether the credit score is known or not. If a credit bureau has not been pulled, the dealer requires that an average rate be used to quote the first pencil. If a credit bureau has been pulled, a published rate matrix determines what rate must be used on the first pencil.

Additional policy requirements include the disclosure of term, no more than 45 days to first payment; always use 12 payments per year; do not include undisclosed F&I products; do not add leg; and keep the payment spread to $5 or less.

While a kink can still pack payments using an edesking system just as easily as if she were still using a Sharpie and a four-square, the edesking system tracks the history of the pencils. Using such software, I can tell what the first pencil is and if it is compliant with the dealership’s desking policy. I can tell if the manager had a credit approval in hand and quoted a payment in excess of the approval’s max rate. I can tell if the number of days or number of payments per year were manipulated to pack the payment.

In fact, it is easier for me (or a member of the Dark Side) to verify that the payments are packed when an edesking software is used. This is a huge benefit for the dealer principal to understand who is following the dealership’s desking policy and compliance training and who the rogue kink is.

Gil Van Over is the executive director of Automotive Compliance Education (ACE) and the founder and president of gvo3 & Associates. Email him at

Your Comment

Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:
Your Name:  
Your Email:  


So Here's the Deal

Ronald J. Reahard
Addressing F&I’s Internet Problem

By Ronald J. Reahard
A frustrated F&I manager poses an increasingly common question: How do you sell protection products to customers who demand the final price by phone and then show up with a bank check?

(Video) Selling Eight Products Without Losing the Customer

By Ronald J. Reahard
Is offering eight products a bad idea? The magazine’s resident F&I pro says it depends on the producer and the presentation.

He Had a Goal: Remembering David Ressler

By Ronald J. Reahard

[Video] Selling to Short-Term Owners

By Ronald J. Reahard

Done Deal

Gregory Arroyo
Change Is Happening

By Gregory Arroyo
Saddened by the potential loss of another piece of his childhood, the editor tries to put the pieces together when he realizes there’s a good lesson to be learned in a toy retailer’s likely demise.

Who Will Take Up the CFPB's Torch?

By Gregory Arroyo
The CFPB’s acting director tells state regulators there will no longer be ‘regulation by enforcement,” but the editor believes there’s a long list of regulators waiting to take up the torch.

Military Lending Act Guidance: The Gift That Keeps On Giving

By Gregory Arroyo

Resolution Needed

By Gregory Arroyo

Mad Marv

Marv Eleazer
Overcome Your F&I Weaknesses

By Marv Eleazer
His Madness issues a challenge to every F&I professional: Eradicate your bad work habits, diversify your lender spread, and check your God complex at the door.

Proper Deal Structure Moves Mountains

By Marv Eleazer
His Madness has a simple but powerful piece of advice for newbie F&I managers and those struggling to adapt to the way finance sources are rating credit-challenged car buyers.

Show Us Some Love

By Marv Eleazer

Chargeback Prevention

By Marv Eleazer

On the Point

Jim Ziegler
Sharpen Your Survival Skills

By Jim Ziegler
‘Da Man’ has a plan you can use to survive the collapse of the car business and remain profitable through the dealer apocalypse.

Sales Rock Stars Still Exist

By Jim Ziegler
Da Man says $40,000-a-month sales rock stars still exist. He says you’ll find them on YouTube and Facebook Live.

The New Stooges

By Jim Ziegler

Is Your Quick Lube Driving Away Business?

By Jim Ziegler