The Industry's Leading Source For F&I, Sales And Technology

Compliance

Fair Warning

Now, more than ever, dealers are left with unanswered questions about finance reserve, discriminatory lending and other regulatory concerns. Two attorneys share their opinions on those topics with F&I and Showroom.

May 2013, F&I and Showroom - Feature

by Stephanie Forshee

Legal experts Rob Cohen and Michael Charapp co-authored “Auto Dealer Law,” a legal guide covering the purchase, sale and operation of car dealerships. The two attorneys sat down with F&I and Showroom to give their candid views on the state of the industry, the future of the F&I department and what dealers can expect from the consumer protection agencies.

F&I: There’s been a lot of talk about the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) interfering with dealership practices, with finance reserve being the most recent example. Just how close is the F&I department to losing finance reserve?

Charapp: If finance reserve systems ended, I’m not sure what the future of the F&I department is. I don’t mean to be dark about this, but if the reserve system ended, there are certain things that will not be cost effective to keep an F&I department. I think the pressure will be extreme, but I think the system is so important to the proper functioning of the retail system among dealers that there will be pushback, so I don’t see it going away. But there are going to be some real battles over this.

Cohen: I agree. If they try to eliminate finance reserve, I don’t think that would stand legal scrutiny. Finance reserve is a significant source of an F&I manager’s income; it’s not just a kickback, as some of the plaintiffs’ attorneys and consumer groups call it. It does not actually result in consumers paying higher interest rates. That’s a falsehood.

F&I: So what do you think consumer advocates and even regulators are missing when it comes to dealer participation?

Rob Cohen is the president of Auto Advisory Services, as well as senior auto counsel at Arent Fox and director of Motor Vehicle Software Corporation.
Rob Cohen is the president of Auto Advisory Services, as well as senior auto counsel at Arent Fox and director of Motor Vehicle Software Corporation.

Cohen: Dealers are a retail outlet for financing. Wholesale financing is always cheaper than retail financing. That’s the whole idea. If consumers were unable to go to dealers for their financing, there is this misconception out there that the rates would be so much lower, that these rates without the yield spread would be so much lower, that dealers are making all this unnecessary profit as a result. It’s simply not true.

Can you buy a car directly from the factory? No, you have to go through a dealership, because they’re the retail outlet. It’s the same thing with vehicle financing. You can’t go directly to Ally and get financing at the same price the dealership is getting it from Ally. It doesn’t work that way. It’s not a markup. It’s not a profit that the dealer is somehow pulling out of thin air. It exists because the dealer is doing the work to arrange the financing. They’re taking the credit application, running the credit report, doing some of the initial underwriting, collecting the information from the customer, accepting a certain amount of risk in doing the delivery of the vehicle, and they’re marketing to these customers. All of these are real, raw costs associated with financing. If the dealer’s not doing that, the finance companies have to do it. And what will that do? It will raise the rates.

F&I: Recent statements issued by the CFPB have indicated it believes consumers are being harmed by discriminatory pricing related to rate markups. What advice do you have for dealers?

Cohen: I think F&I offices need to make sure they are employing consistent pricing practices for all customers, to make sure there is no inadvertent discrimination going on from the lending perspective. They also need to make sure certain groups are not charged more for financing than other groups. I don’t know any dealers that do this intentionally.

Unfortunately, the way the federal law is, unintentional discrimination can still bring liability with disparate impact. I’m a fan of consistent pricing models. That’s what we need — consistent yield, consistent reserves — in order to combat that. Using rate sheets is a great way to ensure that certain groups of customers are not inadvertently charged more or different interest rates than others. The more discretion you give the finance office to adjust rates, the more potential liability there is to the dealership.

F&I: Online advertising still seems to be problematic for dealers from a compliance standpoint. Why is that?

Cohen: One of the largest challenges for dealers right now, depending on which state you live in, is whether there is such a thing as an Internet-only price and a showroom price. Airlines and hotels have their Internet specials. For a dealer in a state like California, if you’re advertising anywhere, you must sell at or below the advertised price. Internet-only specials aren’t allowed. And if you’re missing an expiration date for that special, you must sell it at the advertised price — even if you ran that ad in some abstract newsletter or newspaper that’s generally circulated. So you always have to have expiration dates on your ads.

But if you’re not operating in a state like California, the question remains: Can you have an Internet-only special? If you’re quoting a price electronically to one consumer, the answer is “Yes,” as that does not constitute advertising. Advertising is commuting a message or price generally. But dealers get themselves into trouble in states like California by having this great Internet price, but then they negotiate a price that’s significantly higher with a customer that doesn’t have Internet access. In California, that would be a violation of law.

Michael Charapp, partner at Charapp & Weiss, is the co-author of “Auto Dealer Law.”
Michael Charapp, partner at Charapp & Weiss, is the co-author of “Auto Dealer Law.”

F&I: Are there still areas of concern with electronic disclosures and documentation?

Charapp: When a customer has a problem with a deal, as a lawyer, I’ll call the dealership and ask to see what the customer signed. Invariably, there’s some screen that they tell me the customer saw, but they don’t have it. That doesn’t work.

Cohen: I think it’s risky to rely exclusively on digital signatures in the F&I office. There will come a time when that might work, but I suggest converting everything to paper until we have an industry standard or a definite methodology where you can establish what the customer saw on the screen and how they acknowledged it. A properly trained F&I manager should be going very carefully through all of the documents — whether electronically or otherwise — with the customer to explain everything. I think that’s a struggle we’ve had in this industry forever: properly trained finance people that can carefully and diligently explain all of the documents that the customer is signing. And that doesn’t change whether it’s in paper or electronic form.

Charapp: My rule of thumb in the car business is that if it wasn’t signed, it wasn’t seen. As a lawyer, I can’t prove they saw it if they didn’t sign it.

Comment

  1. 1. Al Levine [ June 01, 2013 @ 12:31PM ]

    What about our Credit Unions and Cudl, who usually pay the dealer one percent of the amount financed and if the customer is a member of the same Credit Union, they will usually get a cheaper rate than the dealer. Its nice to try and retain the customer and we can give him the same rate his credit is giving him, and hopefully we can sell our gap and warranty and still get a little of the reserve they pay. Most dealerships have ajusted the finance pay plan to lower the rate to sell products and bonuses are usually based on aftermarket products and your per copy. This is why they say the toughest job in the store is finance. Discrimination in finance is hard to judge, when one customer has a different credit score than another and following any of the Banks, Lenders or Credit Unions guidelines the rates will be different.

  2. 2. Al Levine [ June 01, 2013 @ 12:31PM ]

    What about our Credit Unions and Cudl, who usually pay the dealer one percent of the amount financed and if the customer is a member of the same Credit Union, they will usually get a cheaper rate than the dealer. Its nice to try and retain the customer and we can give him the same rate his credit is giving him, and hopefully we can sell our gap and warranty and still get a little of the reserve they pay. Most dealerships have ajusted the finance pay plan to lower the rate to sell products and bonuses are usually based on aftermarket products and your per copy. This is why they say the toughest job in the store is finance. Discrimination in finance is hard to judge, when one customer has a different credit score than another and following any of the Banks, Lenders or Credit Unions guidelines the rates will be different.

  3. 3. Al Levine [ June 01, 2013 @ 12:33PM ]

    What about our Credit Unions and Cudl, who usually pay the dealer one percent of the amount financed and if the customer is a member of the same Credit Union, they will usually get a cheaper rate than the dealer. Its nice to try and retain the customer and we can give him the same rate his credit is giving him, and hopefully we can sell our gap and warranty and still get a little of the reserve they pay. Most dealerships have ajusted the finance pay plan to lower the rate to sell products and bonuses are usually based on aftermarket products and your per copy. This is why they say the toughest job in the store is finance. Discrimination in finance is hard to judge, when one customer has a different credit score than another and following any of the Banks, Lenders or Credit Unions guidelines the rates will be different.

  4. 4. Al Levine [ June 01, 2013 @ 12:35PM ]

    What about our Credit Unions and Cudl, who usually pay the dealer one percent of the amount financed and if the customer is a member of the same Credit Union, they will usually get a cheaper rate than the dealer. Its nice to try and retain the customer and we can give him the same rate his credit is giving him, and hopefully we can sell our gap and warranty and still get a little of the reserve they pay. Most dealerships have ajusted the finance pay plan to lower the rate to sell products and bonuses are usually based on aftermarket products and your per copy. This is why they say the toughest job in the store is finance. Discrimination in finance is hard to judge, when one customer has a different credit score than another and following any of the Banks, Lenders or Credit Unions guidelines the rates will be different.

  5. 5. Al Levine [ June 01, 2013 @ 12:35PM ]

    What about our Credit Unions and Cudl, who usually pay the dealer one percent of the amount financed and if the customer is a member of the same Credit Union, they will usually get a cheaper rate than the dealer. Its nice to try and retain the customer and we can give him the same rate his credit is giving him, and hopefully we can sell our gap and warranty and still get a little of the reserve they pay. Most dealerships have ajusted the finance pay plan to lower the rate to sell products and bonuses are usually based on aftermarket products and your per copy. This is why they say the toughest job in the store is finance. Discrimination in finance is hard to judge, when one customer has a different credit score than another and following any of the Banks, Lenders or Credit Unions guidelines the rates will be different.

  6. 6. Jeff Bennett [ June 06, 2013 @ 01:16PM ]

    I doubt the reserve will dissappear. For example, if a lending institution is paying a dealership one percent of the amount financed to write a loan at the buy rate, that probably will remain. What will might be eliminated, however, is the practice of marking up the buy rate one or two percent because this mark-up is not disclosed to the buyer. Dealerships will probably still make some kind of reserve and F&I professionals will have to sell products to buyers. I agree with Al Levine's opinion about pay plans.

  7. 7. Jeff Bennett [ June 06, 2013 @ 01:16PM ]

    I doubt the reserve will dissappear. For example, if a lending institution is paying a dealership one percent of the amount financed to write a loan at the buy rate, that probably will remain. What will might be eliminated, however, is the practice of marking up the buy rate one or two percent because this mark-up is not disclosed to the buyer. Dealerships will probably still make some kind of reserve and F&I professionals will have to sell products to buyers. I agree with Al Levine's opinion about pay plans.

  8. 8. AL LEVINE [ June 09, 2013 @ 01:15AM ]

    no the rate taken away from finance is about 30 percent of all our profit in finance, all my bonuses are predicated on my per copy. Financing 30,000.00 dollars and getting 300.00 from a credit union for 72 months is a little different than getting a true 2 points from most banks., its huge. Our rates sheets have a, b c and d. best credit score gets the A. if your score is a lot lower you get b to d. Dont matter if you black, white brown or what ever, thats not discrimination. You will notice your per copy dropping and still working your butt off to get someone approved. We deserve to get paid for all the hard work and hours we put in. we are doing the customer a favor and time to get them the best rate we can get for them. We derserve to get rewarded for saving them the time for shopping around themselves and we wind up loosing all our back end, because their lender is going to sell them their warranty and their gap which is not honored anywhere and i just worked all these days for nothing. The toughest position in the store is finance. We keep everything together while being completely compliant and trustwothy to the dealer and customer. my pillow feels a lot softter at nite when i am counting aftremarket products jumping over a fence instead of sheep.I believe in the old theory, sell a car make a friend. It also goes for Finance.I have a 100,000 mile warranty onn my car,I have gap on my car and I have 100,000 mile worth of oil changes. I show it all to every customer and tell them why. its just common sense and everything the unused portion gets refunded when your trade or cancel. if you sold you vehicle privately, how much more is it worth when you can transfer everything to the next customer except gap.. it all goes back to basics, make a frend and they become believers. its just good honest sales work I love making friends and being 100 percent compliant. take a nce guy like me and take away our reserve and its a huge cut for the dealer, profit for the lende

 

Your Comment

Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:
Your Name:  
Your Email: