FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

No Bubbles Here

The auto finance industry continued to quell the subprime bubble talk, with finance sources extending credit to five times more superprime car buyers than deep subprime shoppers.

by Melinda Zabritski
October 4, 2016
No Bubbles Here
4 min to read


In response to a newspaper printing his obituary, Mark Twain quipped, “The report of my death was an exaggeration. The famous quote could be the auto finance industry’s response to all the talk about an impending subprime bubble, as it closed out another quarter showing steady growth and remarkable stability.

What’s clear from Experian Automotive’s second quarter data is the market continued to build on its momentum from the first quarter, with the number of loans made during the period growing for all categories. The exception would be the high-risk tiers, with the share of loans made to car buyers with subprime and deep-subprime credit falling from 23.3% in the year-ago quarter to 22.8%.

Ad Loading...

Second quarter data did show a very slight uptick in delinquencies, with 30-day delinquencies rising 0.03% from the prior-year period to 2.22% of all open automotive loans. But even that increase doesn’t point to a subprime bubble lurking on the horizon. The following is a look at some of the trends that shaped the auto finance industry during the second quarter of 2016. 

Leasing Motors to New High

Leasing was the big story of the second quarter, as the transaction type’s share of all new vehicles financed during the period climbed to an all-time high of 31.44%. That’s up 4.52 percentage points from the second quarter of 2015.

Even used-vehicle leasing showed some life, inching up 0.45 percentage points from a year ago to 3.71%. That’s not to say used leasing is becoming a prime option for car buyers, as the transaction type only accounts for about 40,000 transactions nationally per quarter.

The reason for the continued rise in leasing is transaction prices, with the average monthly payment for a new-vehicle loan coming in at $499. Conversely, the average monthly lease payment in the second quarter was $404.

Ad Loading...

And if car buyers weren’t flocking to leasing, they were agreeing to longer finance terms to keep their monthly payments affordable. In fact, the average new-vehicle loan term crept up to 68 months, while lease terms remained steady at 36 months. Hey, a new vehicle every three years for 20% less than the cost to finance carries a certain appeal for many consumers.

Second quarter data also showed that it wasn’t just the prime and superprime tiers that drove leasing to record levels; the transaction type experienced double-digit percentage growth across all tiers on a year-over-year basis. However, subprime and deep-subprime combined still represents less than 8% of leasing volume.

Used Loan Values Reach All-Time High

One trend that picked up momentum during the second quarter was superprime and prime buyers opting for used. These buyers opted for used 43.3% and 59.9% of the time, respectively representing year-over-year gains of 10% and 6.6%.

On average, a monthly used-vehicle payment was $135 lower than the monthly payment for a new vehicle. This cost savings, supported by continuing improvements in vehicle quality and reliability, spells value as well as reduced cash outlays for these savvy purchasing segments, which were obviously looking to simply avoid a high monthly payment.

Ad Loading...

And it’s that shift that has pushed the average credit score for used-vehicle loans up four points to 648. Conversely, the average credit score for new dropped 10 points to 710 over the same time period.

Credit Unions Up, Finance Companies Down

The period also saw the auto finance industry surpass the $1 trillion mark in total outstanding balances for the second consecutive quarter, with balances totaling $1.027 trillion. Commanding the largest share were banks and captive finance companies, although their market share grew only slightly from a year ago.

Banks grew their share from 34.7% in the prior-year period to 34.8%, while captives also increased their share from 27.3% to 27.7% during the same timeframe. Credit unions experienced the largest percentage increase (8.6%), while finance companies experienced a 13.1% drop in their share.

In Need of Payment Relief

Ad Loading...

It’s clear consumers are looking for relief from high transaction prices, with the average amount financed on a new vehicle rising $1,356 from a year ago to $29,880. And even though the average amount financed for a used vehicle rose 2.25% from a year ago to a record high of $19,101, a used vehicle still represents relief from a skyrocketing average new-car payment that is starting to look more like a mortgage.

Based on Experian’s second quarter data, the growth seen in loan values and the relatively flat state of delinquencies, auto finance’s short-term outlook appears to be good for all finance segments. A steady hand in meting out risk with subprime and deep-subprime customers, as well as the ability to keep payments reasonable across all lending types will definitely keep consumers current on their payments, the market stable, and all bubbles at bay.

Melinda Zabritski serves as senior director of automotive credit for Experian Automotive. Email her at melinda.zabritski@bobit.com.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Auto Finance

A fan of $100 bills sitting on a white envelope
Auto Financeby Hannah MitchellAugust 12, 2026

July Was Hot for Auto Borrowers

Credit proved readily available for many, but most loans left buyers in negative territory, Cox Automotive said.

Read More →
stacks of coins, a calculator, paperwork, and a pair of glasses in the background, text Lender Experience Drives Dealer Decisions, F&I and Showroom
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceAugust 12, 2026

Dealer Lender Preferences Revealed

When lenders provide consistent, fast service, their overall satisfaction scores with dealers greatly improve, according to JD Power research.

Read More →
man sitting at desk using a calculator
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceAugust 10, 2026

Auto Refi Savings Surge

Consumers with 84-month auto loan terms who refinanced saved the most on monthly payments, according to a new report by auto refinancing provider Caribou.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Tiny toy car in front of small stacks of coins
Auto Financeby Hannah MitchellAugust 5, 2026

Subaru Enters Lending Business

The automaker follows other brands in adding captive financing in the U.S., and says the move will strengthen its position here.

Read More →
Man climbing ladder in front of mountain landscape.
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceAugust 3, 2026

Positive Equity Reaches Record High

Mainstream vehicle owners who bought a car seven years ago are likely to have positive equity when trading in for a new vehicle, according to second-quarter Edmunds data.

Read More →
Photo of document next to calculator and inkpen
Auto FinanceJuly 20, 2026

Dealerships Are Paying the Price for Extended Car Loans

Growing negative-equity scenarios mean such lengthy terms should be addressed in a forward-looking way to make them work for the dealer and the consumer down the road.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
silver car in background with hand in front holding out a set of keys, Trade-In Trouble, F&I and Showroom
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceJuly 20, 2026

Trade-Ins in Negative Equity Reach New Heights

As such trade-ins rise in frequency, so do monthly loan payment amounts and interest rates, according to second-quarter data compiled by Edmunds.

Read More →
Two men in suit jackets shaking hands in front of a new-looking white vehicle
Auto Financeby Hannah MitchellJuly 15, 2026

Auto Credit Plentiful

June numbers show lenders are readily granting access, including to risky borrowers, as consumers leverage themselves to take on high prices.

Read More →
Woman's hands holding an wallet empty of cash
Auto Financeby Hannah MitchellJuly 1, 2026

Automotive Consumers Sink Further in Debt

Most financing metrics hit records in the second quarter as more buyers locked themselves into long terms and high monthly payments.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Three men smiling for headshots
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceJuly 1, 2026

Porsche Financial Services Shifts Structure

After 36 years with Porsche, the Financial Services Chief Financial Officer Konrad Riedl is retiring, and the department is realigning its management structure.

Read More →