1.2 Million Buy Used Instead of New
The Great Recession is still weighing heavily on how consumers shop for vehicles, as new-vehicle intenders continue to make the switch to used. It’s a trend automakers should continue to fuel, CNW predicts.
BANDON, Ore. —CNW Research noted in its July newsletter that about 60 percent of consumers and small business owners who purchase a certified pre-owned vehicle were originally in the market for a new car. Driving the switch are home-centric economics, the research firm concluded.
The market research firm said the trend really took shape after the Great Recession, which changed not only buying patterns, but the mindset of vehicle shoppers as well.
“The trend during the 1990s was for a decreasing percentage of new intenders selecting a used vehicle instead. But, beginning in 2005 — prior to the recession — it appeared to begin a slight upward movement or flat, at best, into the two to three percent range,” Spinella wrote. “Beginning in 2009, the upward trend mirrored the ‘90s downward movement with each succeeding year seeing more new intenders electing by used.”
The trend also matches the growth in CPO sales. During the first six months of 2013, nearly six percent of new intenders moved to the used-car column. For the full-year 2013, this translates into more than 1.2 million potential new-car buyers switching to used, Spinella noted. And the majority of those switching to used are selecting one- to five-year-old models, he added.
“About 98 percent of used-vehicle shoppers, including those who dropped out of the new-car market, say they would definitely consider an off-lease certified model,” Spinella wrote. “That figure has been growing steadily over the past decade.”
CNW also noted that repo vehicles are suffering under this new trend. “At one point in 1997, fully 70 percent of used intenders said they would consider a repossessed vehicle with only six percent saying they would definitely not consider a repo,” Spinella wrote. “Dial the time machine forward to the first half of this year and only 31.8 percent say they would definitely consider a repo, with nearly 55 percent saying they definitely would not consider one.”
For automakers, Spinella said the drive to add more vehicles to their growing and profitable CPO fleet relies on having a major insourcing of off-lease vehicles. That means, Spinella continued, more lease incentives, more advertising money spent on CPO units and giving dealers added incentives to sell CPOs.
“Dealers, recognizing the potential, are upping trade-in values by as much as 15 percent for cars and trucks that they consider to be certifiable,” Spinella wrote.
More Auto Finance

New Cars a Tad More Affordable
May averages show that combined circumstances gave auto consumers slightly better buying power for the month, though average prices were up year-over-year.
Read More →
First-Quarter Sees Long Auto Loan Growth
Experian data show more consumers are tapping the method, along with refinancings, to afford buying. Meanwhile, subprime borrowers are getting more access.
Read More →
Mastering Credit Friction
In this video, Josh Krach explains how to turn credit friction into an advantage.
Read More →
April Less Affordable
Based on prices, reduced incentives and slower household income growth, consumers found it more challenging to buy new last month, Cox Automotive reported.
Read More →
Auto Lenders, Consumers on a Tightrope
April borrowing data shows that more consumers are bending over backward to buy vehicles, though subprime lending cooled off for the month.
Read More →
Toyota Financial Services President Replaced
Scott Cooke has served in various roles with Toyota Financial Services for over 20 years, including president and CEO, which he retires from on June 30.
Read More →
Permission or Approval: When to Notify Finance Sources
Credit card down payments, multiple vehicle purchases and even straw purchases can be completed without committing bank fraud, as long as you tell the bank first.
Read More →
At-Risk Auto Borrowers Drive Looser Credit Access
Cox Automotive’s index shows the subprime segment, long loan terms, negative-equity borrowers and down payment amounts all grew in February despite ever-higher vehicle prices.
Read More →
Auto Loan Forecast Bucks Market Trend
Auto loan originations rose over 6% year-over-year in the third quarter of 2025, but TransUnion predicts a slight decline in auto loan growth this year, making it an outlier in the company's overall lending forecast.
Read More →
Auto Credit More Plentiful
Growing access shows greater lender appetite for risk as consumers take on heavier debt burden in an inflated market.
Read More →