California Dealers Join Suit Against Carfax
The mass action, antitrust lawsuit against Carfax now lists more than 500 dealers as plaintiffs. The suit, which originated on the East Coast, has now reached California.
MINEOLA, N.Y. — Close to 380 more dealership owners throughout the country have joined the $50 million mass action, anti-trust lawsuit against CARFAX, which was originally filed in late April and now involves more than 500 car dealers. Leonard Bellavia, lead counsel on the lawsuit, noted that 29 of the plaintiffs are located in “The Golden State.”
The suit was brought forth by Bellavia, founding partner of the Mineola, N.Y.-based law firm Bellavia, Blatt, Andron & Crossett, PC. Dealers listed in the complaint argue that they have been overpaying for CARFAX’s vehicle history reports (VHRs) due to CARFAX blocking competitors by signing exclusive agreements with key industry players, thus preventing dealers from selecting a VHR provider of their choice and negotiating a fair price.
The plaintiffs claim that these exclusive deals result in grossly inflated pricing and unreliable vehicle history reports, which create conflicts between the car dealers and their customers.
“The number of car dealers from the state of California showing interest in this case exceeded my expectations,” said Bellavia. “Due to the ongoing concerns among hundreds of car dealerships regarding Carfax’s activities over the years, there has been little hesitation for dealership owners to join our suit.
“Dealerships and consumers have suffered because of Carfax’s tactics, which gouge dealers, and we assert that this legal action is a strong step towards putting an end to the provider’s unfair practices.”
Plaintiffs are also seeking to recover treble damages (three times the overcharges) for six years as well as legal fees.
For more information and to access documents which outline the claims and the costs of participation, click here.
More Auto Finance

Dealerships Are Paying the Price for Extended Car Loans
Growing negative-equity scenarios mean such lengthy terms should be addressed in a forward-looking way to make them work for the dealer and the consumer down the road.
Read More →
Trade-Ins in Negative Equity Reach New Heights
As such trade-ins rise in frequency, so do monthly loan payment amounts and interest rates, according to second-quarter data compiled by Edmunds.
Read More →
Auto Credit Plentiful
June numbers show lenders are readily granting access, including to risky borrowers, as consumers leverage themselves to take on high prices.
Read More →
Automotive Consumers Sink Further in Debt
Most financing metrics hit records in the second quarter as more buyers locked themselves into long terms and high monthly payments.
Read More →
Porsche Financial Services Shifts Structure
After 36 years with Porsche, the Financial Services Chief Financial Officer Konrad Riedl is retiring, and the department is realigning its management structure.
Read More →
Tariffs Could Raise Insurance Premiums
As U.S. import tariffs affect repair costs, consumers might find it more affordable to replace a damaged vehicle, according to recent Insurify tariff analysis.
Read More →
Smaller Loans, Longer Terms
The youngest generation of car buyers is more likely to finance less expensive vehicles, more than half of generation Z consumers borrowing less than $25,000.
Read More →
New Cars a Tad More Affordable
May averages show that combined circumstances gave auto consumers slightly better buying power for the month, though average prices were up year-over-year.
Read More →
First-Quarter Sees Long Auto Loan Growth
Experian data show more consumers are tapping the method, along with refinancings, to afford buying. Meanwhile, subprime borrowers are getting more access.
Read More →
Mastering Credit Friction
In this video, Josh Krach explains how to turn credit friction into an advantage.
Read More →