Delivering the Beef
The AFIP’s executive director opens up about what he hopes to accomplish when he meets with the top brass at the CFPB.

The catchphrase in Wendy’s iconic fast food ads crystallizes a universal expectation that applies to more than just hamburger meat. And when I meet with the CFPB assistant director, tangible proof of performance will most certainly be on his mind. He’ll be asking, “Where’s the beef?”
The Association of Finance & Insurance Professionals will deliver hard evidence of the industrywide effort to ensure that a statistically significant number of car buyers are treated ethically and in accordance with state and federal regulations.
In meeting with the CFPB, the AFIP is acting in its capacity as a nonprofit association serving professionals who ply the F&I trade. We took our first step in 2013 when we submitted the AFIP Certified F&I Professional course to the bureau for vetting.
In addition, we related that after certifying nearly 50,000 people, we had reports of less than a handful of F&I practitioners getting their dealers in trouble. We also provided a roster of the dealers and dealer groups who demonstrate their commitment to regulatory compliance and ethics by maintaining fully certified F&I staffs.
Two major “Where’s the beef?” initiatives will be presented in the meeting. First, select captive lenders and aftermarket vendors are conducting self-monitoring programs to rectify regulatory deficiencies in stores in real time. For each of their dealer clients, this program qualifies as a key element of a CFPB-recommended compliance management system.
The two-phase program calls for the AFIP certification of dealer contact field operatives and the development of a proprietary regulatory compliance checklist. If, during a service call, a rule-savvy dealer-support person identifies a deficiency, it is recorded on the checklist to alert the dealer principal. The field operative then coordinates corrective action related to the vendor’s products and services.
The results have exceeded expectations. Recently, an AFIP certified field operative on a dealer call, armed with a proprietary checklist, cross-referenced a copy of an etch agreement with the entries posted to the corresponding installment sale contract. In doing so, he exposed — and stopped — the practice of an F&I practitioner burying a $700 etch policy in the deal.
The number of participants is growing, and the checklist concept is expanding beyond vehicle sales. I’m seeking permission from participating lenders and vendors to list them by name in my report to the CFPB.
Second, the regional AFIP Certification Boot Camps focus on the regulatory acumen and ethical parameters maintained by in-dealership F&I managers. The boot camps are aggressively promoted by lenders, vendors and general agents. The sessions are also promoted by select state dealer associations.
The past practice of limiting certification classes to a specific dealership or client has been replaced by training that is open to all dealers within a geographic area. The second key benefit is that, after a reasonable preparation period, certification can be achieved in two days with sessions held outside the dealerships.
On the first day of boot camp, key course information is addressed in depth. After an evening study period, a final exam review is conducted the morning of the second day, with a proctored exam administered in the afternoon. A second two-day boot camp is normally held to certify those unable to attend the first session.
As for the beef, the data generated by the boot camp sessions indicate a higher-than-average first-time pass rate and above-the-norm exam scores. The boot camp’s primary benefit, however, is its effectiveness in putting a growing number of regulatorily competent F&I managers in front of car buyers.
In a perfect world, the beef would always be bigger than the bun. But we’re not in the business of making hamburger patties. Franchised dealerships are grappling with an estimated 27 million new- and used-vehicle retail transactions this year that are the result of open negotiations between the buyer and the seller.
When considering the number of permutations that may come into play — lease, finance, cash, and aftermarket product selections — no two deals are identical. And no single solution or flat fee is capable of providing a mutually equitable remedy. In a sense, we’re dealing with a bun of infinite size.
It is AFIP’s intent to demonstrate that a cadre of regulatory-competent, in-store personnel will put enough beef in the bun to make a hamburger worth serving.
David Robertson is executive director of the Association Finance and Insurance Professionals. Email him at david.robertson@bobit.com.
More Auto Finance

Automotive Consumers Sink Further in Debt
Most financing metrics hit records in the second quarter as more buyers locked themselves into long terms and high monthly payments.
Read More →
Porsche Financial Services Shifts Structure
After 36 years with Porsche, the Financial Services Chief Financial Officer Konrad Riedl is retiring, and the department is realigning its management structure.
Read More →
Tariffs Could Raise Insurance Premiums
As U.S. import tariffs affect repair costs, consumers might find it more affordable to replace a damaged vehicle, according to recent Insurify tariff analysis.
Read More →
Smaller Loans, Longer Terms
The youngest generation of car buyers is more likely to finance less expensive vehicles, more than half of generation Z consumers borrowing less than $25,000.
Read More →
New Cars a Tad More Affordable
May averages show that combined circumstances gave auto consumers slightly better buying power for the month, though average prices were up year-over-year.
Read More →
First-Quarter Sees Long Auto Loan Growth
Experian data show more consumers are tapping the method, along with refinancings, to afford buying. Meanwhile, subprime borrowers are getting more access.
Read More →
Mastering Credit Friction
In this video, Josh Krach explains how to turn credit friction into an advantage.
Read More →
April Less Affordable
Based on prices, reduced incentives and slower household income growth, consumers found it more challenging to buy new last month, Cox Automotive reported.
Read More →
Auto Lenders, Consumers on a Tightrope
April borrowing data shows that more consumers are bending over backward to buy vehicles, though subprime lending cooled off for the month.
Read More →
Toyota Financial Services President Replaced
Scott Cooke has served in various roles with Toyota Financial Services for over 20 years, including president and CEO, which he retires from on June 30.
Read More →