FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Menu Selling Reloaded

F&I trainer believes new technology and expert salesmanship can combine to create an efficient and productive menu-selling process.

Rick McCormick
Rick McCormickColumnist
May 4, 2018
Menu Selling Reloaded

Photo courtesy of iStock. 

5 min to read


At Industry Summit 2015 this past September, there were numerous presentations of the newest technology being utilized to make the F&I menu presentation more interactive and time-efficient. I’m amazed at the advancements that have taken place in just the last 12 months. We have turned a corner with the availability of user-friendly, DMS-integrated menu software that shaves time off the overall process and makes for a professional presentation to the customer.

This next-generation technology will usher in a new era in the F&I process and the experience we deliver to our customers. The challenge, however, is to ensure we maximize the advantages it provides without allowing it to become the main focus of the process. Menus, in any format, do not move customers to buy F&I products; experienced and intentional F&I professionals do. Let’s take a look at seven keys to effectively utilize the menu process to help customers make great buying decisions.

Ad Loading...

1. Good Needs Discovery

The options on the menu are not products we sell; they are answers to a problem or a need identified by the person sitting on the other side of the desk. Having a conversation with your customer as you complete the pre-menu paperwork will provide the information needed to uncover a customer’s need for the products offered.

2. Proper Introduction

The menu is simply a disclosure form, so the introduction should not say anything different. “Bob, before we finish up the paperwork, I need to go through this disclosure form with you. I’m required to review your repayment, risk management and vehicle protection options and answer any questions you may have. Would that be OK with you?”

Customers want to know what their options are. They do not want anyone to try and sell them extra stuff. So eliminate words that scream “selling.” These are “additional products” or “things you can add” are deal killers. Make it a simple effort to disclose the customer’s options in a non-selling environment and the customer will ask questions and buy products.

Ad Loading...

3. Collapse Confrontation

When customers interrupt your disclosure and say, “I don’t want any of that stuff,” they subconsciously feel you will stop the process if they exhibit confrontational behavior. So it is imperative you stop the process and acknowledge their statement, thereby collapsing the confrontation. Always give the customer an out.

“No problem!” you might say. “These are all options. You can take all of them, none of them or some of them. Here at XYZ Motors, we feel we have a responsibility to review all the options available to you in connection with your purchase and answer any questions you may have so you can make the right decision for you and your family. Would that be OK with you?”

In my experience, most customers will then allow you to continue.

4. Give Them Ownership

Ad Loading...

When reviewing the options available, it is important we convey that these are their options, not ours. Words such as “we offer” or “we have included” convey the wrong message. Use the word “your” clearly and often to give them psychological ownership.

“This is your vehicle service agreement. It will pay for the cost of both parts and labor for covered repairs on your new Honda Accord.” Make them mentally give back the options they do not want. That is their choice.

5. No Selling the First Time Through

Simply tell the customer what each product is and what it does in a short and concise manner. We want them to ask for more information later, so we must only give them a short description the first time through the menu. The minute you start attempting to sell a product, the walls of resistance go up. Our goal is to keep those walls down throughout the menu presentation so we can have a productive dialogue afterward.

6. Make Them Thirsty

Ad Loading...

After a customer says “No,” the next step will determine how effective you will be. The key to consultative selling is to make customers want to know more about the products we offer. You are responding to their request for information, not making a sales pitch. Make a statement that piques their curiosity and makes them thirsty to know more.

“That surprises me,” you say, “especially since you are buying a car built since 2010.” This will make them want to know what has changed since 2010. We could just tell them how different a vehicle is today. The information is the same. However, effectively getting a customer to ask for more information is the key to turning your next “No” into a “Yes.”

7. Ask Them to Buy a Package

Once the customer has accepted a product, circle it in the first option — which should include all your products — and ask, “Do you want to go with the service agreement in the ‘Preferred’ or would ‘Standard’ be better?” One of the main goals of the menu process is to have customers buy packages, not individual products. It minimizes step-selling and always points them to a package.

Today’s customers want an efficient process that provides the information they need in a format with which they are comfortable. Consider presenting six products or less to reduce the time needed to initially go through the menu.

Ad Loading...

Remember, less is more. The customer drove us to provide a menu format in the first place. Now continue to give them what they want with a professional, nonconfrontational and timely process that puts all their options in front of them in a timely manner. They will reward you by buying more products than you could ever sell them.

It is an exciting time to be in F&I. Cutting-edge technology is evolving at breakneck speed. Just make sure the guiding principles of presenting the information are in place. George Washington never owned an iPad and Abraham Lincoln didn’t have Internet access. We have created remarkable people without technology. We also have created unremarkable people with technology. Let’s make the best of both worlds: a remarkable process with principles that move customers to buy and the amazing technology to make it exciting.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Auto Finance

man sitting at desk using a calculator
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceAugust 10, 2026

Auto Refi Savings Surge

Consumers with 84-month auto loan terms who refinanced saved the most on monthly payments, according to a new report by auto refinancing provider Caribou.

Read More →
Tiny toy car in front of small stacks of coins
Auto Financeby Hannah MitchellAugust 5, 2026

Subaru Enters Lending Business

The automaker follows other brands in adding captive financing in the U.S., and says the move will strengthen its position here.

Read More →
Man climbing ladder in front of mountain landscape.
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceAugust 3, 2026

Positive Equity Reaches Record High

Mainstream vehicle owners who bought a car seven years ago are likely to have positive equity when trading in for a new vehicle, according to second-quarter Edmunds data.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of document next to calculator and inkpen
Auto FinanceJuly 20, 2026

Dealerships Are Paying the Price for Extended Car Loans

Growing negative-equity scenarios mean such lengthy terms should be addressed in a forward-looking way to make them work for the dealer and the consumer down the road.

Read More →
silver car in background with hand in front holding out a set of keys, Trade-In Trouble, F&I and Showroom
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceJuly 20, 2026

Trade-Ins in Negative Equity Reach New Heights

As such trade-ins rise in frequency, so do monthly loan payment amounts and interest rates, according to second-quarter data compiled by Edmunds.

Read More →
Two men in suit jackets shaking hands in front of a new-looking white vehicle
Auto Financeby Hannah MitchellJuly 15, 2026

Auto Credit Plentiful

June numbers show lenders are readily granting access, including to risky borrowers, as consumers leverage themselves to take on high prices.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Woman's hands holding an wallet empty of cash
Auto Financeby Hannah MitchellJuly 1, 2026

Automotive Consumers Sink Further in Debt

Most financing metrics hit records in the second quarter as more buyers locked themselves into long terms and high monthly payments.

Read More →
Three men smiling for headshots
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceJuly 1, 2026

Porsche Financial Services Shifts Structure

After 36 years with Porsche, the Financial Services Chief Financial Officer Konrad Riedl is retiring, and the department is realigning its management structure.

Read More →
$100 bill and magnifying glass on top of paper that says insurance policy terms and conditions.
F&Iby Lauren LawrenceJune 29, 2026

Tariffs Could Raise Insurance Premiums

As U.S. import tariffs affect repair costs, consumers might find it more affordable to replace a damaged vehicle, according to recent Insurify tariff analysis.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Red toy car sitting on top of coins.
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceJune 24, 2026

Smaller Loans, Longer Terms

The youngest generation of car buyers is more likely to finance less expensive vehicles, more than half of generation Z consumers borrowing less than $25,000.

Read More →