FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

CFPB Releases Preliminary Arbitration Research

On Wednesday, the CFPB released preliminary research on the use of arbitration clauses in connection with consumer financial products and services. While auto was excluded from the review, the report’s findings make similar provisions used in auto transactions look ‘consumer-friendly by comparison,’ says legal insider.

December 12, 2013
3 min to read


WASHINGTON, D.C. — On Wednesday, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) released preliminary research on the use of arbitration clauses in connection with consumer financial products and services. The study found that more than 90 percent of the arbitration clauses examined by the bureau explicitly bar consumers from participating in class arbitrations. 

“If you were to look in your wallet right now, the chances are high that one or more of your credit cards, debit cards, or prepaid cards would be subject to a pre-dispute arbitration clause,” said CFPB Director Richard Cordray during a field hearing on arbitration in Dallas today.

Ad Loading...

The bureau was created with the passage of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010. Under the act, the CFPB is required to study the use of pre-dispute arbitration contract provisions in connection with the offering of consumer financial products or services, and to provide a report to Congress. The preliminary research released Wednesday is part of an ongoing study.

Consumer advocates have long argued that arbitration clauses hurt consumers, as arbitrators often side with the company or service provider during a dispute. The CFPB’s research found that arbitration clauses were also significantly more daunting to consumers than the credit card agreements associated with them.   

“Regardless of who was using them, arbitration clauses in credit card agreements were almost always more complex and written at a more demanding grade level of readability than the other parts of the contracts we studied,” Cordray noted. “In fact, in every case, the rest of the credit card contract scored better in terms of readability than did its arbitration clause considered alone.”

The research concluded that very few consumers use arbitration at all, at least when compared to the number of consumers involved in lawsuits and class actions. In the second phase of the bureau’s study, “we will look to see what happens to arbitration filings and endeavor to compare what we see happening in arbitration to what we see happening in litigation, including class litigation,” Cordray added. 

Earlier this year, Tom Hudson predicted that the CFPB would ultimately eliminate arbitration agreements from auto transactions as a result of its review of such agreements. Like other auto industry members, he suggested that the CFPB’s first move would be to eliminate arbitration agreements from auto transactions. Instead, the bureau targeted rate markups first.

Ad Loading...

“The smart money says we’ll see an across-the-board prohibition of arbitration agreements in connection with consumer financial services,” Hudson wrote in February.

The research released this week did not touch on auto finance, instead focusing on credit cards and bank cards. Hudson told F&I and Showroom via e-mail that what the bureau has found so far might be good news for the auto industry.

“Another thing I noted was that the bureau’s listing of the various anti-consumer features, or lack of pro-consumer features, of the arbitration agreements that it had found in these other product areas will make the arbitration provisions in common use in the vehicle finance market look very consumer-friendly by comparison,” he said.

More Compliance

Concertina wire outside a prison

Hoodwinking the Man – Being Out of Trust

Reflections on past cases in which financing sources were defrauded highlight the risks of running afoul of laws regarding this category of fraud.

Scrabble tiles  spelling out 'Rules' among random letter tiles, all on a wooden surface

Variations on a Theme – Lease Packing

Dealers must be careful they don’t run afoul of the law when it comes to such deceptive practices, as there are many cases pointing to the potential bad ends of such deals.

A checkbox on a sheet of paper checked in red
Compliance•by Penelope Bell•August 10, 2026

Your 10-Point Compliance Checklist

Identify areas of concern and opportunities for training by updating, installing and enforcing a compliance checklist that requires specific actions for sales, F&I and accounting.

Ad Loading...
Photo of grass growing a crack of a road with a car's wheel in the background
Compliance•by Terry O'Loughlin•June 24, 2026

A Continuing Antediluvian Dealer Fraud: Payment Packing

The longtime illegal practice, which can take many forms, can get a dealer and its employees in deep trouble. It’s a good idea to determine if anyone in your stores is doing it and to weed it out if so.

Photo of suited man's hands over a computer keyboard
Compliance•by Jim Ganther•June 19, 2026

Line 1 Is Not a Junk Drawer

Rolling products into the cash price — even if the bank told you to — misrepresents the vehicle’s value and runs afoul of four federal laws.

Photo of two skeletons playing banjos
Compliance•by Terry O'Loughlin•May 12, 2026

Dueling Banjos in the Car Biz

Reports and accounts at variance show auto dealers’ trust profiles have risen in many consumers’ minds but that there remains a need for greater transparency by some.

Ad Loading...
Photo of a man signing a paper at a desk while a man in a suit looks on
Compliance•by Terry O'Loughlin•April 20, 2026

NADA and the Miracle on 34th Street

Automotive dealers should follow the National Automobile Dealers Association's consumer-friendly guidelines in order to minimize their legal risks.

Compliance•February 6, 2026

Another Look at a Recent Data Breach

Get caught up on the most pressing legal and regulatory matters facing dealers and F&I professionals, including data security, shotgun purchases, and inconsistent payment quotes.

Compliance•November 26, 2025

Turnover and Compliance

Why ongoing training is a necessity

Ad Loading...
Compliance•November 10, 2025

Singing a Gospel Song Backward

Crime and punishment in auto retail and how to avoid them