FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

4 Steps to Maximize Pre-Owned Profits

Reconsider every aspect of your sourcing, reconditioning, marketing, and lead-generation efforts to get the biggest bang for your used-vehicle buck.

by Bill Wittenmyer
September 19, 2019
4 Steps to Maximize Pre-Owned Profits

Data mining and targeted marketing can help ensure you will find a buyer for every used unit on your lot.

Photo by marchmeena29 via Getty Images

3 min to read


Why are so many dealers prioritizing used inventory? Because cars, with an average price tag of over $34,000, are out of reach for many of today’s price-conscious consumers. But they still want a new-to-them vehicle.

Not surprisingly, sales of new vehicles are expected to decline through the end of the year, but used-vehicle sales are surging. In some ways, marketing and selling pre-owned vehicles is easier than with new cars. Each vehicle is unique, so competition is light.

Ad Loading...

The downside? You could end up stocking aging inventory that costs you money every day.

So how do you maximize vehicle profitability? These four tips will help you create a sound strategy.

1. Source Vehicles From Customers.

Purchasing vehicles at auction is getting expensive. You can pay almost-retail prices at an auction and still get stuck with a vehicle that needs costly repairs to be frontline ready.

It’s much more cost-effective to source vehicles from current customers using equity mining.

Ad Loading...

With this strategy, you already know the car, there are no transfer or auction fees, you’re not competing against other dealers, and you may be able to sell the customer another vehicle. That’s a true win.

A data mining tool can help you identify owners in a position of equity. When combined with thorough follow-up and a strong BDC, equity mining is proven to deliver an ROI of 10 to one — for every $1,000 spent, you’ll get $10,000 back.

Another way to acquire pre-owned vehicles? Follow what major online used-car retailers are doing. Offer free appraisals and no-obligation purchases of used vehicles.

2. Move Vehicles Fast.

The average holding cost for a vehicle is $37 a day, according to NCM Associates. It’s clear that when a vehicle sits on your lot, it doesn’t take long for your profit potential to shrink away. You need to recon fast and stay on top of aging inventory.

Ad Loading...

Streamline your reconditioning process, photography, and vehicle description page creation to get vehicles in front of customers within days. The industry standard is to sell a vehicle in 30 days or less to maintain profitability.

Use an inventory management tool to monitor your inventory. Don’t wait until a vehicle has been sitting around for 30 days to figure out why it’s not moving. Instead, look at every vehicle at the 15- and 20-day mark.

If the vehicle isn’t moving, adjust marketing or have sales staff prioritize the sale.

3. Create Compelling Marketing.

Whether you are marketing new or used inventory, you need to give consumers a reason to buy.

Ad Loading...

CPO programs vary by brand. Identify your program’s best-selling points and highlight them in your marketing and on VDPs. Sell consumers on detailed inspections, reconditioning, extended warranties and peace of mind.

A targeted marketing strategy can help you identify the best potential customers for a vehicle and send personalized offers or messages.

4. Nurture Your Leads.

The pre-owned sales cycle is generally shorter than new, but following up on leads is still critical.

Look at daily sales activities in your CRM, including appointments set, outbound calls, connected calls, length of calls, emails, and texts.

Ad Loading...

Are your salespeople offering more than one pre-owned option in their replies? How many times have they called the prospect?

Remember: It takes an average of five tries to reach someone on the phone. Hold your sales team accountable for making and logging the attempts.

When you start to prioritize your pre-owned profits, remember to source vehicles from customers, move cars quickly, create compelling marketing, and nurture your leads. These four strategies are key to maximizing your profits while making both you and your customers happy.

Bill Wittenmyer is vice president of sales, layered apps, and competitive accounts at CDK Global. Contact him at bill.wittenmyer@bobit.com.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Showroom

Photo of sold Ford store exterior
Showroomby Hannah MitchellMay 11, 2026

Mid-Atlantic Ford Store Has New Owner

A growing Maryland automotive group is only the 93-year-old dealership’s third owner after its longtime proprietors retired.

Read More →
groundbreaking ceremony for new Barrington Porsche dealership with Murgado Automotive Group and Joseph Nicholas Construction
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceMay 11, 2026

Porsche Dealership Breaks Ground in Illinois

Barrington Porsche will be the new location for Murgado Automotive Group’s existing Porsche dealership currently in the Motor Werks of Barrington auto mall.

Read More →
aerial view of Fireside Honda in Ohio
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceMay 6, 2026

Michigan Auto Group Acquires Ohio Rooftops

Feldman Automotive Group added two new brands, Honda and Toyota, to its portfolio with its latest acquisition of four Fireside dealerships in Ohio.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of Scout Terra pickup truck outside farm building
ShowroomMay 4, 2026

California VW Dealers Go After Scout

The franchisees’ state-level actions follow a California auto dealers trade group lawsuit against the VW affiliate last year, both efforts to stop the EV maker’s plan to sell direct to consumers.

Read More →
Photo of rear of Mercedes VLE passenger van
Showroomby Hannah MitchellApril 27, 2026

EVs Gain Traction in Europe

First-quarter auto sales increased as more consumers took advantage of government incentives. Hybrid deliveries are leading the way on the electrifieds boom.

Read More →
road winding through redwood trees, California EV Market Cools, F&I and Showroom logo
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceApril 22, 2026

California Holds EV Lead Despite Annual Decline

At nearly 14%, California had the lowest zero-emission vehicle market share in the first quarter since the fourth quarter of 2021, according to the California New Car Dealers Association.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of Ford F-150 grill with nameplate
Showroomby Hannah MitchellApril 20, 2026

Will Extended-Range Autos Make Inroads?

EREVs, also known as ‘series hybrids,’ may catch on in the U.S., where they currently have barely a toehold, as automakers tilt away from some purely electric models and consumers crave more range.

Read More →
Cars on road in European city
Showroomby Hannah MitchellMarch 30, 2026

Electrifieds Lead EU New-Vehicle Sales

Hybrids in particular lead not only EV market share but all power trains on the continent so far this year as gas and diesel continue their decline.

Read More →
Hyundai steering wheel, black leather
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceMarch 30, 2026

Hyundai Expands North American Footprint

Building on a previously announced $26 billion U.S. investment, Hyundai said it will grow its North American lineup and U.S.-based production and parts sourcing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Image of Honda 'H' emblem
Showroomby Hannah MitchellMarch 25, 2026

Afeela EV Brand Fails to Leave the Factory

Sony-Honda venture cancels two planned models, the first of which had been pegged for a mid-2026 California delivery debut. The brand’s direct sales had been challenged by the state’s auto dealers, but the venture cites Honda’s EV retreat.

Read More →