FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Gabler Attorney Questions Prosecution Evidence

An attorney for indicted Pennsylvania dealer and former association head Andy Gabler has filed a motion accusing prosecutors of failing to document instances of alleged fraud.

Tariq Kamal
Tariq KamalFormer Associate Publisher
Read Tariq's Posts
November 26, 2019
Gabler Attorney Questions Prosecution Evidence

A team led by U.S. Attorney Scott W. Brady is pursuing federal fraud charges against Pennsylvania dealer Andy Gabler. Gabler’s attorney says the prosecution has failed to turn over sufficiently detailed documentation.

2 min to read


ERIE, Pa. — A discovery motion filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania urges prosecutors to turn over more detailed documentation of fraud charges against Andy Gabler, owner of the Erie-area Lakeside Auto Sales and Lakeside Chevrolet and former head of the National Independent Automobile Dealers Association.

Gabler and Chad Bednarski, who worked as an F&I manager for the three-rooftop group, were indicted on 17 counts of conspiracy and fraud in August. The prosecution, led by U.S. Attorney Scott W. Brady, charged the pair with falsely reporting down payments and income on loan applications and reporting phantom sales, costing financier S&T Bank approximately $1.88 million.

Ad Loading...

Read: Feds: NIADA’s Gabler, F&I Manager Indicted for Fraud

But the defense attorney who filed the motion, Elliot Segel, claims he has yet to see the proof. Prosecutors have turned over thousands of documents, none labeled to correspond with listed charges, Segel said, and lists of transactions only include dates — no customer or vehicle information, loan amounts, or other specifics that could be used to defend the case.

“This has literally been akin to searching for the proverbial needle in a giant haystack,” Segel told Erie News Now.

A trial date has not yet been set. If convicted, Gabler could be sentenced to up to 510 years in prison and $17 million in fines. Bednarski faces a maximum sentence of 330 years and fines totaling $11 million.

Read: Gabler Resigns NIADA Post Following FBI Raid

Ad Loading...

Originally posted on Auto Dealer Today

More Compliance

Concertina wire outside a prison

Hoodwinking the Man – Being Out of Trust

Reflections on past cases in which financing sources were defrauded highlight the risks of running afoul of laws regarding this category of fraud.

Scrabble tiles  spelling out 'Rules' among random letter tiles, all on a wooden surface

Variations on a Theme – Lease Packing

Dealers must be careful they don’t run afoul of the law when it comes to such deceptive practices, as there are many cases pointing to the potential bad ends of such deals.

A checkbox on a sheet of paper checked in red
Compliance•by Penelope Bell•August 10, 2026

Your 10-Point Compliance Checklist

Identify areas of concern and opportunities for training by updating, installing and enforcing a compliance checklist that requires specific actions for sales, F&I and accounting.

Ad Loading...
Photo of grass growing a crack of a road with a car's wheel in the background
Compliance•by Terry O'Loughlin•June 24, 2026

A Continuing Antediluvian Dealer Fraud: Payment Packing

The longtime illegal practice, which can take many forms, can get a dealer and its employees in deep trouble. It’s a good idea to determine if anyone in your stores is doing it and to weed it out if so.

Photo of suited man's hands over a computer keyboard
Compliance•by Jim Ganther•June 19, 2026

Line 1 Is Not a Junk Drawer

Rolling products into the cash price — even if the bank told you to — misrepresents the vehicle’s value and runs afoul of four federal laws.

Photo of two skeletons playing banjos
Compliance•by Terry O'Loughlin•May 12, 2026

Dueling Banjos in the Car Biz

Reports and accounts at variance show auto dealers’ trust profiles have risen in many consumers’ minds but that there remains a need for greater transparency by some.

Ad Loading...
Photo of a man signing a paper at a desk while a man in a suit looks on
Compliance•by Terry O'Loughlin•April 20, 2026

NADA and the Miracle on 34th Street

Automotive dealers should follow the National Automobile Dealers Association's consumer-friendly guidelines in order to minimize their legal risks.

Compliance•February 6, 2026

Another Look at a Recent Data Breach

Get caught up on the most pressing legal and regulatory matters facing dealers and F&I professionals, including data security, shotgun purchases, and inconsistent payment quotes.

Compliance•November 26, 2025

Turnover and Compliance

Why ongoing training is a necessity

Ad Loading...
Compliance•November 10, 2025

Singing a Gospel Song Backward

Crime and punishment in auto retail and how to avoid them