Ky. Dealer Charged With Leading $4M Repurchase Fraud
A federal grand jury has charged a Kentucky dealer and two alleged accomplices with defrauding a manufacturer — thought to be Toyota — of more than $4 million by running 350 used pickups through a consumer buyback program.

Three Kentuckians stand accused of perpetrating a $4.3 million interstate fraud against an unnamed vehicle manufacturer by putting hundreds of trucks through a buyback program intended only for individual owners.
Photo by Gary Scott via Pixabay
CHARLESTON, W.Va. — A federal grand jury has returned an indictment charging three Kentucky residents with 10 counts of fraud and identity theft relating to a scheme to defraud a major car company of more than $4 million, announced United States Attorney Mike Stuart.
Stuart said James Pinson, 44, Gary Conn, 56, and, Tammy Newsome, 53, organized and participated in a scheme to misuse a car company’s warranty extension program that offered to repurchase certain trucks for 150% of their value — so long as those trucks were owned by individual customers rather than a dealership.
Read: Hyundai Claims Dealer Fraud Forced $5M in Repurchases
Participants in the scheme bought the trucks at wholesale prices at auction through Pinson’s car dealership, Big Blue Motor Sales of Louisa, Ky. They then obtained hundreds of copies of Kentucky and West Virginia residents’ driver’s licenses, fraudulently titled the trucks in the name of those residents, and induced the car company to repurchase the trucks at 150% of value, all according to the indictment.
Prosecutors believe the defendants ran 350 trucks through the scheme between 2013 and 2015, causing approximately $4.3 million in losses to the car company. Newsome is also charged with aggravated identity theft. Frank Russo, 68, of North Carolina and Kevin Fluharty, 58, of West Virginia have already been indicted for their role in the same scheme.
If convicted, the three defendants face up to 30 years in prison.
“At the time of the alleged scheme, Toyota offered a buyback program for trucks that had their frames rusted out.”
“This is the second indictment setting forth very serious allegations of a long-term warranty fraud scheme,” Stuart said. “Five individuals have now been charged in connection with the alleged fraud scheme that resulted in $4 million in losses.”
The aggrieved party was not named in court documents. Courtney Hessler of the Huntington, W.Va., Herald-Dispatch speculated the “major car company” is Toyota.
“At the time of the alleged scheme, Toyota offered a buyback program for trucks that had their frames rusted out. Toyota’s policy for the buyback was to purchase the affected vehicles for 1½ times their value, based on the Kelley Blue Book calculation for vehicles in ‘excellent’ condition,” Hessler wrote.
Originally posted on Auto Dealer Today
More Compliance

Dueling Banjos in the Car Biz
Reports and accounts at variance show auto dealers’ trust profiles have risen in many consumers’ minds but that there remains a need for greater transparency by some.
Read More →
NADA and the Miracle on 34th Street
Automotive dealers should follow the National Automobile Dealers Association's consumer-friendly guidelines in order to minimize their legal risks.
Read More →
Another Look at a Recent Data Breach
Get caught up on the most pressing legal and regulatory matters facing dealers and F&I professionals, including data security, shotgun purchases, and inconsistent payment quotes.
Read More →

The Best Thing a Dealer Can Do to Avoid Legal Problems
Citing the issue is a strategy borrowed from the legal field itself.
Read More →
Fines of the Times
Civil penalties for noncompliance with federal auto retail and finance rules and regulations can add up quickly. Use this checklist to cover your bases.
Read More →
Goodwill and Car Dealers
A dealer goodwill tale is a cautionary tale worth paying attention to.
Read More →
The Regulatory Empire Is Striking Back
President Trump - entropist and corporate disruptor in consumer law
Read More →
How to Clear a Red Flag
Refine and enforce your dealership’s FTC-mandated ID theft-prevention program to ensure no transaction goes awry.
Read More →
