Scot Eisenfelder Takes Helm as CEO of APCO Holdings, LLC
Eisenfelder joined APCO as Senior Vice President, Strategy and Planning in August 2020.

Eisenfelder joined APCO as Senior Vice President, Strategy and Planning in August 2020.
NORCROSS, Georgia– APCO Holdings, LLC, a leading provider and administrator of automotive F&I products and home to the EasyCare, GWC Warranty and MemberCare brands, announced that Scot Eisenfelder has been named CEO, effective May 1st, 2021. Eisenfelder joined APCO as Senior Vice President, Strategy and Planning in August 2020.
We have several exciting new initiatives planned, including the expansion of core offerings that will help our customers thrive in a digital retail world.
APCO Holdings’ current Chairman and CEO, Finbarr O’Neill, will assume the position of Executive Chairman.
“I look forward to continuing the strategic direction that Fin has set here in the last two years,” said Eisenfelder. “We have several exciting new initiatives planned, including the expansion of core offerings that will help our customers thrive in a digital retail world. We will also continue to expand our offerings in the credit union, recreational vehicle and direct to consumer channels.”
O’Neill, 69, will relinquish his role as CEO upon completion of a two-year commitment. As Executive Chairman, O’Neill will oversee strategic direction and senior management development.
“When we recruited Scot to join the board in 2019, we knew he would be an excellent fit at APCO, due to his deep automotive industry experience and keen understanding of the critical role of automotive dealers in the industry. Over the last year he has taken on increasing levels of responsibility, demonstrating at each step he is more than capable of leading APCO to new levels of growth,” said O’Neill.
In his two years as Chairman and CEO of APCO Holdings, O’Neill has helped drive a number of changes including bringing more focus on the core business, shedding extraneous initiatives, upgrading systems, improving processes and preparing for the impact of digital retail on the automotive industry.
Prior to joining APCO Holdings, Eisenfelder was Executive Chairman and CEO of Affinitiv, Inc., a leading provider of data-driven marketing and retention solutions. As Senior Vice President, Strategy at AutoNation, Eisenfelder led significant initiatives to drive retail innovation. He also led JM Family’s dealer software business and was Senior Vice President of Product Management, Strategy and Marketing at Reynolds and Reynolds, delivering profitable growth for both companies. Eisenfelder holds an MBA from the Wharton Business School, graduating with distinction as a Palmer Scholar. He attended Mannheim University in Germany as a Fulbright Scholar and graduated summa cum laude in Economics from Princeton.
Originally posted on Auto Dealer Today
More Awards

Small-Town Dealership Awarded for Advocacy
Ellis Automotive in upstate New York was named the 2025 Dealer of the Year by Donate Life NYS for promoting organ, eye and tissue donations and fundraising.
Read More →
Voting Now Open for 2026 Dealers' Choice Awards
Voting is now open for the 22nd annual Dealers’ Choice Awards, a program designed to recognize auto dealers’ favorite vendors, suppliers, and finance partners.
Read More →
Hyundai, Kia Lead Electrified Awards
With more hybrids and EVs on the market, U.S. News & World Report expanded its 2026 Best Hybrid and Electric Cars awards and introduced the first 'best hybrid minivan' class.
Read More →
F&I Hall of Fame 2026 Class Inducted at Agent Summit
The selection committee is set to accept nominations for future F&I Hall of Fame members following the induction of the Class of 2026 at last week’s Agent Summit.
Read More →
Honda Sweeps Awards for Consumer Zeal
The automaker takes all the mass-market Kelley Blue Book shopper awards except for pickup trucks, while Lexus dominates luxury lines.
Read More →
Auto Journalists Crown 2026 Winners
The worldwide body’s judges test-drove candidates over months as they narrowed down a field of eligible models. BMW garnered three separate honors.
Read More →
Dealers Awarded for Consumer Reviews
Roughly 1,000 dealerships across the U.S. and Canada were named 2026 Dealer of the Year award winners by Cars.com, which based its list on customer reviews and dealer responsiveness.
Read More →
Automotive Amplifiers Contest Upcoming
The annual Reynolds and Reynolds competition puts automotive retail best practices front and center by showcasing innovations.
Read More →
Crash Avoidance is Top Priority
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety awarded 63 vehicles for safety, and SUVs lead the picks with more than half of the base and Pick+ awards.
Read More →
Hybrids Abound in CR 2026 Top 10 Picks
Based on Consumer Reports’ new Safety Verdict score, Mazda makes the safest new cars on the road at a brand level, the highest percentage of its tested fleet earning the top score.
Read More →