FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Car Finance Markups Hurt African Americans, Study Author Claims

by Staff
October 27, 2000
3 min to read


The author of a study finding that African-American car buyers paid more in car loans than similarly situated white buyers claims the only factor that explains the difference is race.


Dr. Debby A. Lindsey, a business professor at Howard University, analyzed close to 15,000 loans from General Motors Acceptance Corporation (GMAC) and Nissan Motor Acceptance Corporation (NMAC).

Ad Loading...


"Credit worthiness is not even an issue because it is already factored into the buy rate. The only issue is whether the finance companies' policy of allowing markups beyond the buy rate has an adverse effect on African Americans and I concluded that it does," Dr. Lindsey said.


Two federal lawsuits charge the discrimination affected hundreds of thousands of people who financed automobiles over the past 11 years. Lawyers in the class action cases are seeking money back and a change in the auto loan companies' practices.


The suits claim that car dealers were encouraged by GMAC and NMAC, unknown to most consumers, to inflate the costs of car loans for customers they thought would pay higher rates. The car finance companies and the dealerships then split the additional revenue. The plaintiffs' lawyers say it was that policy which resulted in discrimination with blacks typically paying about 50 percent more in dealer markup than whites. The complaints further allege that the finance companies should have foreseen the results and immediately ended the practice as soon as discrimination became apparent.


Federal civil rights law allows for penalties against companies whose policies lead to discriminatory lending or pricing, even if that discrimination is inadvertent and if race is not directly referred to in the policy.


"The record shows that discrimination is bad or even worse for African American car buyers with perfect credit," said Gary Klein, senior attorney with The National Consumer Law Center in Boston, one of several lawyers and law firms involved in the case. "NMAC and GMAC may not know the race of their borrowers, but they engage dealers to arrange the loan terms, and those dealers definitely do know the borrowers' race. We contend that the law makes NMAC and GMAC responsible for all the terms of the loan including those arranged by the dealers."

Ad Loading...


"Markup charges shouldn't be secret," Klein said. "The secrecy encourages dealers to set up loans for consumers not with the lender that offers the best rates, but rather with the lender that kicks back the most markup."


The suits against GMAC, concerning Tennessee car buyers, and the NMAC suit, concerning buyers across the country, are both pending in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District in Tennessee, which sits in Nashville. Both cases were certified in August of this year as class actions. The federal Department of Justice appeared in court in support of the plaintiffs' position. The cases were filed two years ago under seal, but were recently unsealed under pressure from national media.


ABC News' 20/20 featured a report on the investigation on Oct. 27.


Presently, the NMAC case is scheduled for trial in September 2001, and the GMAC case in February 2002.

Topics:F&I

More F&I

Man holding magnifying glass over sales volume paper.
F&IMay 29, 2026

Why Your F&I PVR Is Misleading You

Here’s a handy checklist of the numbers to track in 2026 instead.

Read More →
Photo of woman typing on a laptop as she sits on a couch
F&Iby Hannah MitchellMay 29, 2026

Auto Consumer Anxiety Presents Opportunity

A survey of U.S. drivers found the majority are concerned about finances and the economy, but those fears make many ready to buy vehicle-protection products.

Read More →
Dustin Gingerich standing on stage giving a presentation
F&Iby Lauren LawrenceMay 28, 2026

Humble and Hungry: 12 Rules for an F&I Life

Dustin Gingerich, with a decade in the F&I business under his belt, shares his thoughts on leadership, building trust with customers, and the importance of learning and innovation.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of businessman's hands resting on files on a desk
F&Iby John TabarMay 27, 2026

Focus on the Opening

F&I managers must learn as much as possible about their customers, starting before they walk into their offices. The bulk of today’s consumers expect that, and good results will follow.

Read More →
Photo of a three-seat vehicle back seat
F&Iby Hannah MitchellMay 22, 2026

F&I Reaches for the Sky

The increasingly important profit center continued making gains in the first quarter, according to StoneEagle data, ancillary products proving more popular as consumers hold onto their buys longer.

Read More →
Cover image for a BOK Financial report titled “Timing the market: How avoiding volatility entirely can hurt long-term reinsurance program performance.” The image shows several road construction barricades with flashing amber warning lights lined up in a nighttime work zone. Beneath the image, red text explains that avoiding volatility can mean falling behind inflation and missing market rebounds that drive long-term surplus growth. The BOK Financial logo appears at the bottom right.
SponsoredMay 8, 2026

Timing the Market Can Hurt Long-Term Program Performance

For dealer-owned reinsurance entities, avoiding volatility entirely can mean falling behind inflation and missing market rebounds that drive long term surplus growth. Missing just a handful of strong market days can materially impact cumulative returns—an important reminder for long horizon trust and investment strategies.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Ryan Ruff, The 90/10 Rule, Automotive Training Academy, Sales Series
F&IMay 6, 2026

The 90/10 Rule

In this video, Ryan Ruff explains the rule that elite sales professionals use to turn ordinary conversations into unforgettable customer experiences.

Read More →
Photo of essential oil diffuser on desk next to laptop
F&IMay 4, 2026

Your Office Is Talking

What’s the atmosphere saying about you to your customers? You can make minor adjustments and additions that transform your space into one that creates trust with the people on the other side of the desk.

Read More →
"Effective training ensures the customer’s needs remain at the heart of everything we do. When that is the focus, both sales and profits naturally improve." by Rick McCormick with F&I and Showroom logo and picture of Rick McCormick
F&IMay 1, 2026

F&I Training Fundamentals

How can auto dealerships help F&I managers fulfill their vital role in the most effective ways? Industry expert Rick McCormick shares his insights on the best ways to train these professionals and help them maintain good habits.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of car tire and the tread mark it left in snow
F&Iby Hannah MitchellApril 29, 2026

Not Just Any Tire Will Do

More consumers and businesses are opting for all-season options for various reasons as safety, sustainability and convenience push practical change.

Read More →