FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

CarMax, Asbury, West-Herr Automotive Settle FTC Recall Advertising Charges

The three retailers agreed to settle FTC charges that they touted rigorous inspections while failing to disclose that some vehicles were subject to unrepaired safety recalls. The FTC also finalizes orders against GM and two other sellers in similar cases settled earlier this year.

by Staff
December 19, 2016
4 min to read


WASHINGTON, D.C. — CarMax, Asbury Automotive, and West-Herr Automotive Group agreed to settle Federal Trade Commission (FTC) charges that they touted rigorous pre-owned vehicle inspections but failed to disclose that some vehicles were subject to unrepaired safety recalls, the agency announced on Friday.

The proposed consent orders will prohibit the three major auto retailers from making unqualified inspection or safety-related claims about their used vehicles if any are subject to open or unrepaired safety recalls. The commission also announced it has approved final consent orders in similar cases against General Motors, Jim Koons Management, and Lithia which were settled earlier this year.

Ad Loading...

“Federal law requires that all new cars sold in the United States be free from recalls, but it does not prohibit auto dealers from selling used cars with open recalls. As a result, neither NHTSA nor any other agency has the authority to ban the sale of used cars that have open recalls across the industry,” the FTC said in a statement. “Section 5 of the [FTC Act], however, enable the commission to stop car sellers from engaging in false or misleading advertising practices that mask the existence of open recalls, and we are committed to doing just that.

“As part of this effort, the commission is issuing final orders against General Motors Co., Jim Koons Management CO., and Lithia Motors Inc. and announcing proposed orders against CarMax Inc., West-Herr Automotive Group Inc., and Asbury Automotive Inc.,” the FTC added, in part. “In these enforcement actions, the commission is challenging what we allege are deceptive advertising claims by these companies that highlight the rigorous inspections they perform on their used cars, but failed to clearly disclose the existence of unrepaired safety recalls.”

The FTC’s complaint against Virginia-based CarMax revolves around the retailer’s advertising claims of a “125+ Point Inspection,” and that its cars undergo, on average, “12 hours of renewing — sandwiched between to meticulous inspections.” The complaint also notes a TV commercial touting a team of inspection and reconditioning, which includes a message that appears for three seconds in tiny type at the bottom of the screen that reads, “Some CarMax vehicles are subject to open safety recalls.”

Those recalls, however, included the GM’s key ignition switch defect, as well as the Takata airbag defect, the agency alleged.

AS for Georgia-based Asbury Automotive Group, which also does business as Coggin Automotive Group, and Crown Automotive Group, the FTC alleged in its complaint that the company made claims such as: “Every Coggin Certified used car or truck has undergone a 150-point bumper-to-bumper inspection by certified mechanics. We find and fix problems — from bulbs to brakes — before offering a vehicle for sale.”

Ad Loading...

Like it did in its complaint against CarMax, the FTC charged the group with failing to adequately disclose in its advertising that some vehicles were subject to open recalls, including one that could cause fuel to leak and the engine to misfire or stall, as well as one that could cause a car to move in an unexpected or unintended direction.

In its complaint against West-Herr Automotive Group, the largest auto group in New York, the FTC cites claims about vehicles backed by the “West-Herr Guarantee” and touting a “rigorous multipoint inspection with our factory trained technicians.” However, the FTC’s complaint alleges that the company failed to properly disclose that some of the vehicles were subject to recalls for defects that could result in serious injury.

Under the proposed consent orders, CarMax, Asbury, and West-Herr are prohibited from claiming that their used vehicles are safe, have been repaired for safety issues, or have been subject to an inspection for safety-related issues, unless they are free of open recalls or the companies clearly and conspicuously disclose that their vehicles may be subject to unrepaired recalls. They must also explain how consumers can determine whether a vehicle is subject to a recall for a safety issue that has not been repaired.

In a commission statement regarding the six auto recall advertising cases, the commission notes that its orders “will help empower consumers to make more informed and safer purchasing decisions in a market that, absent a change in federal law, continues to include cars subject to open recalls.” The commission vote to issue the statement was 3-0.

The commission vote to issue the administrative complaints against CarMax, Asbury, and West-Herr and to accept the consent agreements was 3-0. The FTC will soon publish a description of each consent agreement package in the Federal Register. The agreement will be subject to public comment for 30 days, beginning today and continuing through Jan. 17, 2017. At that time, the commission will decide whether to make the proposed consent orders final.

 

More Showroom

Twilight of white hybrid car.
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceJuly 22, 2026

California Hybrids Reach State Record

The Golden State still leads the country in electric-vehicle registrations, but much like the rest of the U.S. its hybrid market share is up while full electrics stabilize after a dramatic first-quarter dip.

Read More →
White meeting room in car dealership with rims displayed on wall and projected screen
Showroomby Hannah MitchellJuly 22, 2026

My Mercedes in the U.S.

The German brand debuted its studio dealership concept for the first time in the states in Los Angeles, tapping Americans’ penchant for creative distinctions.

Read More →
Photo of parked cars of various types for sale on a lot
Showroomby Hannah MitchellJuly 20, 2026

Used Sales Hit Summer Drag

The vacation season, combined with high prices, has dented deliveries and added to inventories, though supply is still slim enough to keep listings elevated.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
desert road with cars driving away, Rebates Incoming with red star graphic, F&I and Showroom logo
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceJuly 15, 2026

California Launches EV Rebate Program

Participating automakers are matching the state's $13.5 million investment in new electric-vehicle rebates scheduled to take effect later this summer.

Read More →
Aerial shot of a car dealership
Showroomby Hannah MitchellJuly 13, 2026

OEM Poll Sees Industry Evolution

Kerrigan Advisors’ survey of automakers finds that tariffs, technology, network tightening and other factors are poised to reshape auto retail.

Read More →
Photo of cars lined up on lot
ShowroomJuly 10, 2026

The Trade-In Paradox

Retailing older cars with confidence in today’s market is a matter of establishing and following a clear process that can turn greater profit for auto dealers as they aim to meet used-unit hunger.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Phot of a dark Kia vehicle interior with steering part of steering wheel and dashboard
Showroomby Hannah MitchellJune 29, 2026

Focus on Vehicle Cabins

The market for interior materials will grow in coming years as automakers look to meet consumer demand while staying competitive with changeups to sourcing and included features.

Read More →
Photo of multiple new SUVs on a car dealership lot
Showroomby Hannah MitchellJune 22, 2026

State Follows Federal Warning on Auto Ads

The Massachusetts attorney general cautioned the state’s automotive dealers to be upfront with the consuming public about their vehicle prices or risk punishment.

Read More →
Map of Europe next to back of EV car.
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceJune 22, 2026

European EV Market Hits Record

Seven out of the top 10 electric vehicles sold so far in 2026 in Europe are by European brands, and automakers are seeing the power train fill up their order books.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Person pumping gas into car.
Showroomby Lauren LawrenceJune 17, 2026

Used EVs Outpace New

While North American electric-vehicle sales remain down year-over-year, May sales saw a 3% increase from April’s numbers as used EVs led the market.

Read More →