FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Clay Nissan Settles $1.5M Defamation Suit

The legal battle between Clay Nissan and the brothers of a former cancer-stricken employee is over, ending the family’s 10-month campaign against the dealership for terminating their sister.

by Staff
May 14, 2013
3 min to read


NORWOOD, Mass. — The 10-month social media boycott against Norwood, Mass.-based Clay Nissan is over, with the two lawsuits related to the “Boycott Clay Nissan” settled outside of court earlier this month.

The campaign was launched in June 2012, just days after Jill Colter was terminated from her service writer position at Clay Nissan. Her brothers, Adam and Jonathan, claimed Jill was fired because she had cancer, and then took to social media to boycott the dealership. Jill filed a discrimination case against the dealership’s owner Scott Clay, who then filed a $1.5 million countersuit against her brothers for defamation.

Ad Loading...

On May 3, Adam Colter, who was the driving force behind the boycott, posted a letter to his nearly 57,000 Facebook followers, announcing that the case had been settled.

Clay confirmed the news in an e-mail to F&I and Showroom, saying, “Yes, the Colter family and the Clay family worked things out, and I believe everyone is as happy as could be with the resolution.”

Erik Syverson, a Los Angeles-based Internet defamation attorney who originally shared his insights with F&I and Showroom during the height of the boycott, wasn’t surprised by the settlement, saying that at least 95 percent of such cases never make it to trial.

“What I have seen [among Internet defamation cases] is usually the larger, wealthier plaintiff party might agree to dismiss the case just for removal of the content. That’s a possibility here,” Syverson says.

Both Clay and Colter refused to comment on any terms of the settlement, but Syverson says it’s completely possible that no money was exchanged at all since the point of a defamation case is to end the negative image being portrayed online.

Ad Loading...

In Adam Colter’s Facebook post to the boycott followers, he painted a far cleaner picture of the dealership than back in December when he spoke to F&I and Showroom. “… This was such an emotional issue for all involved and when emotions run high, there can be unintended collateral damage to people and their lives on both sides,” read his Facebook post. “Those certainly were never our intentions and to those people, we offer our most sincere apologies …

“I can honestly say that the good I have seen in Scott Clay and his family far outweighs any derogatory posts I may have made toward the Clay’s. In fact, I wholeheartedly encourage everyone that was either directly or indirectly involved with this site to kindly disregard any negative comments I may have made toward the Clay Family.”

Colter said his note would be his final posting on the matter. He also stated that the Facebook page, as well as the campaign’s Twitter account and website, would be deleted. All three were removed on May 9. Posts, however, made to Change.org still appear, but a page authored by Jonathan Colter shows a request for his petition to be deleted from the site.

Content on Clay Nissan’s ClayFamilyCares.com was also removed from the site, which now says it is “undergoing maintenance.”

With the removal of the content from sites like Facebook, “Boycott Clay Nissan” is no longer among the No. 1 search results page for the dealership on Google — where several of the top search results were previously overtaken by boycott pages.

Ad Loading...

Syverson addressed the removal of the boycott sites, saying that’s the ultimate goal in most cases. “That would be something you would typically see, both in a settlement or if you went to trial with the jury and received a judgment,” he explains. “That’s what’s driving the litigation.”

—     Stephanie Forshee


More F&I

Laptop computer, tablet, calculator and notebook on a desk
F&Iby John TabarAugust 20, 2026

Just Do It

F&I managers need training, but instead of resisting application or expecting perfection, they should improve by simply acting on what they learn.

Read More →
stacks of coins, a calculator, paperwork, and a pair of glasses in the background, text Lender Experience Drives Dealer Decisions, F&I and Showroom
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceAugust 12, 2026

Dealer Lender Preferences Revealed

When lenders provide consistent, fast service, their overall satisfaction scores with dealers greatly improve, according to JD Power research.

Read More →
Leading with Purpose thumbnail. Trent white pictured in front of titled graphic.
F&IAugust 5, 2026

Leading with Purpose

In this video, Trent White explains how understanding your people’s 'why' is a key leadership responsibility of F&I professionals and how that mindset drives dealership engagement, trust and performance.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of a keyring with mltiple keys, including a car key fob, on a white surface
F&IJuly 15, 2026

Integrating Nontraditional F&I Products

The niche presents a strategic advantage for auto dealerships as they move to adapt to fast-changing consumer expectations in today’s market.

Read More →
Photo of businessman's hands holding eyeglasses at a desk
F&Iby Rick McCormickJuly 7, 2026

Trust Is Personal

Technology, no matter how efficient, can’t replace what the human F&I manager can do, which is to bridge the divide between cyberspace and the in-store experience.

Read More →
Photo of executive in a sports coat and glasses
Industryby StaffJuly 2, 2026

Amplify 2026 Billed as Turning Innovation Into Results

Reynolds and Reynolds says its annual retail summit will connect dealers with practical strategies, peer insight, and technology-driven ideas.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Woman standing on stage smiling.
F&Iby Lauren LawrenceJuly 1, 2026

Own Your Outcome: F&I in the Digital Customer Journey

Finance has historically been the last step in the car-buying process, but it doesn’t have to be. The customer’s journey starts long before they arrive at the dealership, and so should F&I’s involvement.

Read More →
$100 bill and magnifying glass on top of paper that says insurance policy terms and conditions.
F&Iby Lauren LawrenceJune 29, 2026

Tariffs Could Raise Insurance Premiums

As U.S. import tariffs affect repair costs, consumers might find it more affordable to replace a damaged vehicle, according to recent Insurify tariff analysis.

Read More →
Red toy car sitting on top of coins.
Auto Financeby Lauren LawrenceJune 24, 2026

Smaller Loans, Longer Terms

The youngest generation of car buyers is more likely to finance less expensive vehicles, more than half of generation Z consumers borrowing less than $25,000.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Under the hood of a Toyota Prius EV Hybrid car.
F&Iby StaffJune 15, 2026

New Lifetime Battery F&I Product Meant to Drive Dealer Traffic

EFG Cos. offering is intended to create lifetime auto dealer engagement with customers.

Read More →