Kontos: Tale of Two Markets Resumes in March
While wholesale prices were below year-ago levels for cars, they were up for trucks. The revelation prompts KAR Auction Services' chief economist to revisit a study he began during the industry's first experience with $4 gas back in 2008, when the price gap between trucks and cars closed dramatically.
CARMEL, Ind. — The tale of two markets resumed in March, with wholesale prices below year-ago levels for cars (down 1.7%) but up 1.3% for trucks, according to KAR Auction Services’ Tom Kontos.
Prices for both groups, however, were up (2.2% for cars and 1.4% for trucks) compared to February’s unseasonably soft results, as retail sales and wholesale activity showed signs of the typical spring/tax season trends, Kontos added.
“In analyzing the current bifurcated market, it seems timely to revisit a study begun during the first episode of $4 gas in 2008, when truck prices softened dramatically and car prices rose,” Kontos wrote in his Monthly Kontos Kommentary. “At that time, the price gap between full-size SUVs and compact cars had fallen from close to $13,000 in January of 2000, when SUVs were all the rage, to $2,162 in June of 2008, when gas prices hit $4 a gallon. In other words, dealers were paying high prices for small cars and low prices for big SUVs at the time, narrowing the price gap between the two. That turned out to be the all-time low for this price gap, which gradually rose to $8,293 by November 2016 as gas prices have fallen and the popularity of SUVs has recovered.
“Per our March data, this gap has dropped to $6,675, perhaps indicating that SUV prices are moderating and compact car prices are recovering,” Kontos added. “We will monitor this going forward.”
According to ADESA Analytical Services, wholesale used-vehicle prices in March averaged $10,904, up 2% compared to February and up 1% relative to March 2016. All but on model class segment (compact pickups) showed month-over-month increases. Minivans showed the biggest increase year-over-year increase (13.5%), but Kontos said the growth was exaggerated by newer models.
Average wholesale prices for used vehicles remarketed by manufacturers were up 1.1% on a month-over-month basis but down 1.7% year over year. Prices for fleet/lease consignors were up 3.8% sequentially and up 0.8% annually. Average prices for dealer consignors were up 2.7% vs. February and up 1.3% relative to March 2016.
“Breaking the data down by age shows that prices were down 2.5% year over year for current and one-model-year-old units (typically off-rental units) and down 2.6% for three-model-year-old units (a good proxy for off-lease units),” Kontos noted.
Based on data from the NADA Used Car Guide, retail used-vehicle sales by franchised and independent dealers were up 9.3% month over month and up 1.6% year over year. March certified pre-owned sales were up 15% month over month, although they were down 0.3% year over year from last March’s all-time record levels, according to figures from Autodata.
More Auto Finance

Auto Loans Easy to Come By in October
Captive lenders led the way for the month as some riskier shares rose, resulting in a loan approval rate approaching 75%.

Auto Finance Fraud Flourishes
Synthetic identities account for the majority of vehicle financing crimes, making dealerships’ prevention efforts a vital step in the process.

Interest Rates Further Squeeze Auto Consumers
Last month’s hike and a potential second increase this month add to a growing list of inflation woes that could continue to dent overall car sales.

Mind Your Process
Consistent steps taken in various aspects of the F&I office can make valuable differences over time, similar to an outline for a best-selling book.

Top Five Credit Application Fraud Flags
Compliance audits regularly reveal bad habits that can lead to fraud charges and should have been stamped out decades ago.

More Auto Loans for the Taking in August
Riskier categories were on the uptick for the month as lenders loosened access in several areas while balancing out the exposure in another, Cox Automotive reported.

July Was Hot for Auto Borrowers
Credit proved readily available for many, but most loans left buyers in negative territory, Cox Automotive said.

Dealer Lender Preferences Revealed
When lenders provide consistent, fast service, their overall satisfaction scores with dealers greatly improve, according to JD Power research.

Auto Refi Savings Surge
Consumers with 84-month auto loan terms who refinanced saved the most on monthly payments, according to a new report by auto refinancing provider Caribou.

Subaru Enters Lending Business
The automaker follows other brands in adding captive financing in the U.S., and says the move will strengthen its position here.
