Study: Used Car Profit Gap Closing
A survey of 250 U.S. franchised dealerships revealed a 21% drop in the gross-margin gain between new- and used-vehicle sales as off-lease units flooded the market in 2017.


Used-car owners are 50% less likely to visit their selling dealership for service and 25% less likely to buy another car from that dealership, according to AutoLoop. Illustration by Yonkers (N.Y.) Honda via Flickr
CLEARWATER, Fla. — The gross margin gap between the sale of used and new vehicles dropped 21% in 2017. And that's despite the share of used-car sales rising from 40.2% in 2016 to 40.7% last year, according to a new report.
The report, “The Impact of Used Car Sales on Your Service Drive," was released today by marketing, sales and service solutions provider AutoLoop LLC. It summarizes the company’s analysis of used-vehicle sales data from more than 250 franchised dealerships.
“This is both good and bad news for auto dealers,” said Doug Van Sach, AutoLoop’s vice president of analytics and data services. “The good news is we’re seeing increased opportunities to sell more vehicles. The bad news is that the gap between new and used profit is shrinking as more off-lease vehicles flood the market.”
“If this trend continues,” Van Sach explained, “dealers will see their service business gradually erode as fewer customers make the journey from the showroom to the service drive.”
Used owners are 50% less likely to visit the dealer for maintenance and repairs, and they are 25% less likely to return to a dealer to buy another car. Because of this, dealers who rely solely on a manufacturer’s retention marketing program are particularly vulnerable to losing used-vehicle service business, as many of these programs ignore used-vehicle owners.
One possible solution? Van Sach suggests dealers develop a separate customer retention and marketing program for their used vehicle customers. “Make used customers aware of your service value proposition, and offer them targeted service specials based on their unique needs.”
Visit AutoLoop at Booth 5038C at the NADA convention in Las Vegas.
More F&I

Integrating Nontraditional F&I Products
The niche presents a strategic advantage for auto dealerships as they move to adapt to fast-changing consumer expectations in today’s market.
Read More →
Trust Is Personal
Technology, no matter how efficient, can’t replace what the human F&I manager can do, which is to bridge the divide between cyberspace and the in-store experience.
Read More →
Amplify 2026 Billed as Turning Innovation Into Results
Reynolds and Reynolds says its annual retail summit will connect dealers with practical strategies, peer insight, and technology-driven ideas.
Read More →
Own Your Outcome: F&I in the Digital Customer Journey
Finance has historically been the last step in the car-buying process, but it doesn’t have to be. The customer’s journey starts long before they arrive at the dealership, and so should F&I’s involvement.
Read More →
Tariffs Could Raise Insurance Premiums
As U.S. import tariffs affect repair costs, consumers might find it more affordable to replace a damaged vehicle, according to recent Insurify tariff analysis.
Read More →
Smaller Loans, Longer Terms
The youngest generation of car buyers is more likely to finance less expensive vehicles, more than half of generation Z consumers borrowing less than $25,000.
Read More →
New Lifetime Battery F&I Product Meant to Drive Dealer Traffic
EFG Cos. offering is intended to create lifetime auto dealer engagement with customers.
Read More →
The Psychology Behind Menus That Increase Add-On Sales
There is a science to crafting a menu that gives customers confidence in the choices presented, and moving the process outside the F&I office can further boost results.
Read More →
Why Your F&I PVR Is Misleading You
Here’s a handy checklist of the numbers to track in 2026 instead.
Read More →
Auto Consumer Anxiety Presents Opportunity
A survey of U.S. drivers found the majority are concerned about finances and the economy, but those fears make many ready to buy vehicle-protection products.
Read More →