FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

4 Ways to Identify Motivated Car Shoppers

Equity mining remains one of the most reliable sources of appointments and sales. Expert lists the four key areas you need to focus on to improve your closing ratio in 2020.

by Scot Eisenfelder
January 27, 2020
4 Ways to Identify Motivated Car Shoppers

The ability to upgrade one’s vehicle is not always accompanied by motivation. The author urges dealers to focus their equity mining efforts on four reliable indicators.

Photo by vadimguzhva via Getty Images

3 min to read


While the average vehicle ownership length is 6.5 years, trade-ins peak around three years into the loan term. This means approximately 10% to 15% of existing dealer customers are eligible to upgrade their vehicles at any given time.

Equity mining tools have long been used to identify sales and service customers with equity in their vehicles, in the hopes of turning them into new sales customers. Most tools have built-in templates that help dealers create attractive, personalized purchase offers that reflect both short term and long term cost-of-ownership savings.

Ad Loading...

Read: Data Mining: The Golden Opportunity You’re Ignoring

However, there is one drawback to equity mining tools: Just because a customer has the ability to upgrade their vehicle does not necessarily mean they have the motivation to do so.

What if you could further streamline customers identified by your equity mining tool to include only motivated customers? You could increase new vehicle sales by focusing all your time, marketing dollars, and efforts on customers with both equity and a need.

The best way to identify motivated customers is to filter a list using several other, knowable triggers that indicate when consumers may be the most open to a new vehicle sales offer. These triggers include:

1. Warranty Expiration or Collision

Ad Loading...

Is the vehicle near warranty end or out of warranty? Does the vehicle have excess mileage? Is the vehicle coming off lease in the next year? These triggers are easy to identify and allow you to contact vehicle owners far in advance of the actual event.

Also identify owners who may have lost confidence in their vehicle. Has there been a recent collision repair? Has the customer declined a service estimate over $500? Loss of confidence is a powerful purchase motivator.

2. Change in Life Event

Purchase data from third parties that will help you identify customers and prospects who have recently experienced life changing events. These events are great indicators that vehicle needs may change.

Recent movers into your primary market area can be targeted with a welcome message and sales offer.

Ad Loading...

Newlyweds, newly divorced, college graduates, and parents with new babies or high school students all make great targets. So do people who have started a new job.

When a potential car buyer visits your dealership website, third-party sites, or an OEM website, you know that person is a hot prospect.

3. Online Browsing Behavior

Online browsing behavior is one of the best predictors of who is currently in-market. Fortunately, new technology exists that allows you to identify “anonymous” shoppers online and tells you what they’re looking for.

When a potential car buyer visits your dealership website, third-party sites, or an OEM website, you know that person is a hot prospect. Being able to identify who they are allows you to send them custom, personalized messages guaranteed to grab their attention and pique engagement.

Ad Loading...

4. Location, Location, Location

Technology also exists that allows you to track prospects’ locations. What if you could be notified when an existing customer attends the local auto show or visits a competitor’s lot? This would allow you to serve them display ads or videos designed to grab their attention and place your brand in consideration.

When combined with equity mining data, these triggers become a powerful predictor of customers who are both eligible and motivated to buy. These customers are worth targeting with aggressive, personalized, and relevant omnichannel campaigns to ensure that your message is being heard and your brand is in consideration.

Scot Eisenfelder is CEO of Affinitiv, a marketing technology company serving automotive manufacturers and franchise dealers. Email him at scot.eisenfelder@bobit.com.

Read: 8 Ways Small Dealers Can Compete With Big Franchises

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Digital

Adapting to Digital For a convenient and trustworthy experience, F&I and Showroom
DigitalJune 1, 2026

F&I in the Digital Age

Digital retailing has not made the F&I manager obsolete. If anything, it has revealed how valuable the role can become when technology is used correctly.

Read More →
Hands holding phone over graphic.
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceMay 27, 2026

Need for Speed: EV Apps Lack Consistency

Fifty-five percent of surveyed EV owners said their mobile applications had a major or moderate impact on their purchasing decisions, but connectivity issues remain a problem.

Read More →
Light 'trail' to illustrate the idea of a digital trail
Digitalby Gil Van OverMay 18, 2026

Four Keys to Your Digital Trail Defense

Federal regulators are cracking down on hidden fees. This protective measure could mean the difference between winning and losing a lawsuit or surviving a duel with the Dark Side.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Hyundai Motor Group Tech Talent Forum 2026 September 17-18 San Jose, California. background of starry night
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceApril 20, 2026

Hyundai Hosts Tech Talent Forum

Technology leaders from Hyundai Motor Group will have open discussions at the inaugural HMG Tech Talent Forum on topics ranging from autonomous driving to 'smart' manufacturing.

Read More →
car outline on top of a data background
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceApril 7, 2026

Dealers Seek Actionable AI

Dealers are facing growing frustrations with current generic artificial intelligence tools, according to a survey by Lotlinx, which found they want a solution that understands their inventories.

Read More →
Ron Reahard, president of Reahard & Associates, announcing an integration with ImpactMenu to enhance F&I transaction recording, compliance and dealership performance insights.
Digitalby StaffMarch 19, 2026

Reahard & Associates Forges New Integration

The firm's F&I Insight tie-up with The Impact Group’s ImpactMenu platform is designed to enhance finance-and-insurance transaction recording for auto dealerships.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Chris Walsh, president and acting CEO of Reynolds and Reynolds, promoting the company’s Amplify 2026 event for dealership professionals focused on technology and operations.
Digitalby StaffMarch 13, 2026

Registration Open for Reynolds Amplify Retail Summit

Advancements with Reynolds' AI Agent, Rey, will take center stage this August at the Park Hyatt Aviara in Carlsbad, Calif., near San Diego.

Read More →
A customer signs documents on a digital e-contracting tablet using a stylus while a dealership employee points to the screen, alongside the Reynolds and Reynolds and Assurant logos.
Digitalby StaffMarch 6, 2026

Automotive Training Academy by Assurant Grows Offering

A new Atlanta location on Reynolds and Reynolds' docuPAD e-contracting system is designed to broaden access for auto professionals.

Read More →
A dealership customer works with an F&I representative at a desk during the vehicle purchase process.
Digitalby StaffJanuary 30, 2026

Assurant Debuts Virtual Solution for Dealers' Staffing Challenges

Company says on-demand access to F&I specialists is shown to boost dealership efficiency and profitability.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
DigitalDecember 16, 2025

What to Do When Your Vendor Is Hacked

The quickest way to turn a breach into a crisis is to wing it. Follow this seven-step playbook to ensure you meet your obligations.

Read More →