FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Consumer Group Claims Fraud Rampant at Auto Dealerships

"This is an issue that's pervasive." ~ Joan Claybrook Public Citizen president

by Staff
December 9, 2003
2 min to read


A consumer group wants all state attorneys general to investigate fraud at auto dealerships, saying dealers regularly bilk customers out of hundreds of dollars through price manipulation and costly financing deals, according to an Associated Press (AP) report.


In a report released Dec. 8, Public Citizen cited as an example of fraud an offer for an anti-theft program that etches the vehicle's identification number in the window glass.

Ad Loading...


The service should cost about $100, Public Citizen said, but dealers charged as much as $500. In some cases, customers paid and the service wasn't provided, according to AP.


Public Citizen, a Washington-based group, said customers also may not be told they got the etch service, so they aren't aware that they're eligible for an insurance payment of up to $2,500 if the vehicle is stolen, AP said.


"This is an issue that's pervasive," Public Citizen President Joan Claybrook said, according to the Associated Press. "(Auto dealers) imply that they're you're advocate, but they're not. They're there to make a profit."


The organization based its 71-page report on the claims of Duane Overholt, who worked as an auto salesman in Florida for 20 years before going to federal prosecutors with accusations against his former employer, Charlotte, N.C.-based Sonic Automotive Inc. Sonic Automotive didn't return a telephone call from AP seeking comment Dec. 8.


The group also reviewed lawsuits against dealers filed in nine states, according to AP.

Ad Loading...


The National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) said Public Citizen's report focuses on some extreme cases of fraud in an industry that employs 1.2 million people and sells 40 million new and used vehicle each year, AP noted.


"To suggest that this is part of some kind of national conspiracy is absurd," Chairman Alan Starling said in a statement. "To indict an entire industry is a great disservice to the overwhelming majority of auto dealers who treat each of their customers in an honest and open manner."


But Claybrook warned that "auto dealers will do almost anything to sell a car." She said customers should not obtain financing through a dealership and should remember that dealers make money from add-ons, even if they say that something is being offered for free. Customers also should refuse to sign any blank financial forms, as they are sometimes asked to do if the sale is completed after hours, according to Claybrook, AP reported.

Topics:F&I

More F&I

Woman in casual clothing sitting at a desk
F&Iby Rick McCormickMarch 31, 2026

Curb The Confusion

Talk to F&I customers like you’d talk to a friend, without industry lingo or sales-like questions, and use hard proof to show, not tell, them about a need.

Read More →
Photo of man's hand on laptop computer keyboard with blank screen
F&IMarch 16, 2026

There Is Always one More Product

Helping F&I customers understand complementary offerings is likely to lead to more sales, based on the success of a high-performing practitioner of the philosophy.

Read More →
REGISTER FOR EFI 2026
F&Iby Kate SpataforaMarch 16, 2026

EFI Conference Extends Early Bird Discount as Room Block Nears Capacity

Ethical F&I Manager's Conference will take place at The Cosmopolitan Las Vegas on April 13–15, 2026.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Industryby StaffMarch 6, 2026

Explore the 12 Rules for an F&I Life at EFI

EFI 2026 will take place April 13–15 at The Cosmopolitan Las Vegas.

Read More →
F&IMarch 4, 2026

Creating Your Own Economy

In this video, Reese Dailey explains how effective follow-up drives better results across the dealership, including increased sales, higher F&I penetration, and stronger customer retention.

Read More →
Industryby StaffMarch 2, 2026

Prove You Can Do F&I at EFI

‘So You Think You Can Do F&I’ is a live role-play contest taking place at the 2026 Ethical F&I Managers Conference.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Image of two human hands, one holding the word yes, the other the word no
F&Iby Hannah MitchellMarch 1, 2026

Expect Yes in the F&I Office

It may be human nature to back off when a customer seems to say no to a product or service. But experts say F&I managers should operate as though the answer will be the opposite.

Read More →
Industryby Lauren LawrenceFebruary 25, 2026

Report Finds Year-End F&I Strength

Deal volume ebbed and flowed throughout 2025, but product performance remained steady, according to automotive technology and data intelligence solutions provider StoneEagle.

Read More →
Industryby Hannah MitchellFebruary 23, 2026

Some Auto Brands Cheaper to Insure

A new top 10 list ranks the least expensive for average full insurance coverage on a clean driving record and high driver credit scores.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
F&IFebruary 13, 2026

Business Office Blueprint

Try following these 20 steps to greater success in the dealer F&I office this year.

Read More →