Auto insurance consumers’ trust of insurers is low, negatively affecting satisfaction and brand advocacy.
Over half, or 51%, of the more than 41,000 people who responded to a J.D. Power survey said they have low trust in their insurers.
But despite rate hikes, insurers can gain trust by managing expectations.

U.S. auto insurance rates are up 11% on average over the past year, but insurers are still losing an average of five cents on the dollar in collected premium.
Pexels/Vlad Deep
Auto insurance consumers’ trust of insurers is low, negatively affecting satisfaction and brand advocacy.
Over half, or 51%, of the more than 41,000 people who responded to a J.D. Power survey said they have low trust in their insurers.
One way auto insurers can gain trust is by better managing rate increases, the survey shows. Remarkably, trust levels were almost exactly the same among consumers who fully understood the reasons for a rate increase and expected it as consumers whose insurers cut their rates, or 735 and 736, respectively, on a 1,000-point scale, J.D. Power said.
That’s significant because, despite U.S. auto insurance rates up 11% on average over the past year, the company said insurers are still losing an average of five cents on the dollar in collected premium.
Trust in auto insurers varies depending on which of 11 surveyed regions the consumer lives, and the study found customers in Florida have the lowest level, not surprisingly since rate increases there are more frequent.
The survey, conducted in the eight months ended in April, is in its 25th year.
Originally posted on Auto Dealer Today

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety awarded 63 vehicles for safety, and SUVs lead the picks with more than half of the base and Pick+ awards.
Read More →
The Kerrigan Index shows that despite a chaotic year of musical trade tariffs, high vehicle prices and more roadblocks, acquirers still flush with pandemic-era cash accelerated the consolidation pace.
Read More →
Softening prices, rising credit availability and higher tax refunds could be behind February’s sales pace rise and accompanying dip in inventory, according to Cox Automotive.
Read More →
Reported thefts fell to their lowest level in decades, though the risk is still quite real, especially in large metro areas. Meanwhile, Hyundai and Kia nabbings, though still high, slowed.
Read More →
ISeeCars data shows a significant gap between used and new days on market, used cars sitting 40% longer while new cars are down 15% year-over-year as of February.
Read More →
Gilchrist Automotive has added Team Gillman Chevrolet to its auto group, which has over 20 locations across Texas and Oklahoma. The store will now operate as Gilchrist Chevrolet.
Read More →
Advancements with Reynolds' AI Agent, Rey, will take center stage this August at the Park Hyatt Aviara in Carlsbad, Calif., near San Diego.
Read More →
New-vehicle sales fell year-over-year for the fifth month in a row in February, making retail deliveries the slowest they’ve been since 2023, according to a CarGurus report.
Read More →
Both vehicle values and conversion rates sped up last week as two segments outperformed in the pre-spring burst of buying.
Read More →
Thanks to improvements made to the frame rail of Jeep Wranglers, all units built after October earn an acceptable IIHS rating for a combination of driver- and passenger-side tests.
Read More →