Fresh Auto Consumer Loyalty Perspective
Retention picture changes across power trains, demographics and auto segments, study finds

Industrywide, 38% of auto consumers changing power trains stayed loyal to their previous brands.
Pexels/Brett Jordan
When U.S. auto consumers are in the market for a different power train than their current models, they’re more likely to switch brands for the change-up.
In fact, loyalty to power train type is significantly greater than brand loyalty, S&P Global Mobility says it found. Of households shopping for a new vehicle, 74% stick with the same power trains they’ve had, compared to 51% who stay with the same auto brands.
But consumers switching power trains tend to shop around: 62% of households doing so switched brands at the same time, according to S&P Mobility’s research. The automotive data provider observed the phenomenon among both households switching from gas-powered to alternative-fuel power trains and vice versa.
The pattern presents challenges and opportunities for auto dealers, the challenge of keeping customers in the fold, and the opportunity of winning over a competing brand’s loyalists. S&P says households tend to return to the auto market every 3½ years.
Of those, about half switch brands, it said. But among the three out of four who keep the same power train, 56% stay with the same auto brand they bought from the last time.
The research also found differences among consumer demographic groups and auto market segment.
Between July 2024 and this past June, more Asian households switched both brand and power train than those that changed brands but stuck with the same power trains, S&P said, while just 27% of black households that jumped to new brands also switched power trains.
Meanwhile, a similarly low 26% of luxury auto consumers changing power trains stayed loyal to their previous brands, compared to 38% industrywide and 41% for mainstream brands.
S&P advises auto brands to target their marketing to households open to power train switch-ups in an effort that can at the same time reveal those loyal to their current power trains and brands.
“The more granular your targeting, the more effective your strategy will be,” the report says.
More Showroom

New Cars Less Affordable
Buying conditions eroded for American shoppers last month due to inflation and interest rates, though they fared better than a year ago.
Read More →
October Sales Divided
Inventory trends split between the new- and used-vehicle markets, though prices continued to rise for both in October.
Read More →
Auto Transaction Prices Hit New Height
October sales of big, pricey models push up the average, even as budget-conscious consumers snag more economical options.
Read More →
Making the Safe Choice
Kelley Blue Book has turned households with teen drivers onto safe and affordable options for their vehicles of choice
Read More →
Inventory Holds Steady
September new-vehicle inventory rose slightly month-over-month, but dealer lots are laden with MY2026 vehicles as the typical model year changeover trudges along.
Read More →
October Auto Sales Fall With the Leaves
A forecast anticipates retail deliveries are down this month as consumers continue to face cost challenges, though more are tapping long loans in order to buy.
Read More →
California Sees Quarterly Gains
California’s new-vehicle market saw a boost in hybrids in the third quarter and its first overall quarterly market gain of the year.
Read More →
New-Vehicle Prices Stay Put
Affordability pressures and model availability shaped new-vehicle sales in September, according to an analysis by Kelley Blue Book.
Read More →
EV Buyer Consideration Shifts
What drives American consumers to purchase an electric vehicle is shifting as the question moves away from Should I?' to 'Which features and experience do I want to have?'
Read More →
Year-to-Date Auto Sales Holding Their Own
A forecast through August shows that automakers have shifted strategies to keep deliveries and revenues up despite tariffs and other economic challenges.
Read More →