New Trial Date Set for DealerTrack Patent Infringement Suit
After more than five years in the discovery phase, DealerTrack Holdings Inc.'s patent infringement case against RouteOne LLC and Finance Express LLC is scheduled to go before a jury on Feb. 24 of next year.
SANTA ANA, Calif. — After more than five years in the discovery phase, DealerTrack Holdings Inc.’s patent infringement case against RouteOne LLC and Finance Express LLC is scheduled to go before a jury on Feb. 24 of next year. Judge Andrew Guilford of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California set the new date after ruling on several key pre-trial motions Tuesday.
Judge Guilford’s decisions effectively dismissed two of the three patents in question as well as DealerTrack’s charge of willful infringement in the third. The jury will be asked to determine whether RouteOne and Finance Express violated DealerTrack’s ownership of U.S. Patent No. 7,181,427, which was awarded in March of last year and pertains specifically to DealerTrack’s online credit application processing system.
Finance Express’ founder and president, David Huber, was encouraged by Tuesday’s rulings.
“While we never expected the dismissal of all DealerTrack’s claims, only three out of all their original patent claims remain in the case,” Huber said Wednesday. “The fact that two out of their three patents were found to be either non-infringing or invalid is an incredible victory not only for our company, but the industry in general.”
DealerTrack first leveled the suit against RouteOne in Jan. 2004, alleging that RouteOne had infringed on three patents relating to DealerTrack’s dealer management system (DMS). DealerTrack later filed a joint suit against both RouteOne and Finance Express in Oct. 2006. Counterclaims from both companies against DealerTrack followed, alleging inequitable conduct, among other charges.
RouteOne, which alleged that DealerTrack intentionally withheld pertinent information in the course of the investigation of the remaining patent, also claimed victory Wednesday. RouteOne hopes their claim of inequitable conduct will be proved in the jury trial, which could open the door for both companies to go after DealerTrack to recoup the cost of their legal fees.
“We are gratified by the court’s decision,” said Mike Jurecki, RouteOne’s CEO. “It greatly simplifies this litigation … We are very comfortable with our defenses to the remaining patent claims and, if necessary, will deal with this remnant of the case at trial.”
In a prepared statement, DealerTrack reminded those following the case that only one of the remaining claims must be proven true for their side to prevail, and that the key for the plaintiff in patent litigation is to make it to the trial phase.
“We are firmly committed to protecting our intellectual property rights, including enjoining RouteOne’s and Finance Express’ infringing activities,” said Mark O’Neil, DealerTrack’s chairman/CEO. “We are confident in the merits of our case and look forward to the jury trial in February.”
More Digital

Fixed-Ops Automation Can Help Dealerships Stand Out
Technology turns everyday service repairs into lasting customer loyalty and dealer profitability.
Read More →
AI and the Auto Dealer
These are risks you can’t ignore as the technology becomes more and more of a presence in the auto retail environment.
Read More →
Data Drives Success
Dealerships that make decisions based on data rather than gut instinct or experience have a leg up on their competitors, according to a recent survey.
Read More →
AI: Facilitator, Not Fixer, in F&I
The dealerships that thrive in the years ahead will be those that embrace technology while continuing to invest in the people who make customer interactions count.
Read More →
Simple But Effective Hacking Surges
Data from the past year at U.S. auto dealerships finds that email and identity phishing are growing threat sources that can dispense with malware by exploiting trust.
Read More →
The Future of Car Dealerships
Artificial intelligence is reshaping the service-drive experience and will help retailers stay competitive.
Read More →
Structure Leads to Optimized Auto Listings
As the average car-buying journey has shifted to a blend of digital and retail, a dealership’s vehicle listings must be optimized to answer shoppers’ questions clearly and accurately.
Read More →
Real Intelligence
AI, though it presents many opportunities for productivity, efficiency and more, isn’t a one-for-one stand-in for people. It can augment human capital but not replace it altogether.
Read More →
Zurich Launches Advisor IQ for F&I Manager Coaching
The new platform uses real transaction data and artificial intelligence-driven insights to help car dealerships improve consistency and performance.
Read More →
F&I in the Digital Age
Digital retailing has not made the F&I manager obsolete. If anything, it has revealed how valuable the role can become when technology is used correctly.
Read More →