FI showroom red and grey logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

No Pipe Dreams Here

The head of IAS’s retail software division responds to Marv’s column last month, and offers his perspective on the iPad and mobile tools.

by Matt Nowiciki
April 13, 2012
No Pipe Dreams Here

Matt Nowicki.

4 min to read


Last month, Mad Marv wrote about his reluctance to embrace mobile F&I, and he raised some good questions.
I understand his skepticism. He’s been in “The Box” for many years and has seen any number of next-big-thing solutions come and go. Marv’s numbers are as strong as they come, so I understand why he’d question why anyone would suggest he change his approach.

What Marv issued was a challenge to companies like mine. Yes, I head up my company’s retail software division. But, like you, my paycheck is 100 percent based on F&I products being sold. So, I would never develop or advocate a solution that didn’t result in more products being sold. Remember, I work for a product company, not just a software company.

Now, few things have revolutionized F&I like the introduction of the menu decades ago. In fact, it is now estimated that more than 80 percent of all franchised dealerships use some form of menu selling in the F&I office. It has led to higher penetration rates, more gross per deal, and higher customer satisfaction.

As the lead architect of SmartMenu, I’ve spent the last decade working with agents and dealers to customize, legalize and perfect what is, in my not-so humble opinion, the finest menu program available. And you’d be hard pressed to find a dealer or F&I manager who doesn’t agree that menu selling works.

The IAS tablet-based application, which we call SmartPad, is a tool that shortens the F&I process and helps create sales opportunities by gathering information from the customer in real time as he or she waits to enter the F&I office. SmartPad can be used to provide CSI-styled surveys, but it also is designed to present and gather information in an engaging manner that has never been tried before. And our solution goes beyond the typical survey and interview: We use dynamic video and multimedia presentations to engage the customer in additional purchase opportunities that will be made available once they are turned over to F&I.

Now, while some tablet-based F&I technology may aim to convert a salesperson to a hybrid F&I manager, the SmartPad — and I want to make this clear — does not. We designed it to help streamline functions performed by F&I managers, namely the interview and product presentation process.

I do disagree with Marv that the F&I clock starts ticking the moment the tablet is handed to the customer, because if it’s used properly, the customer should remain in sales mode.

See, we recommend that sales representatives tailor the survey around specific information related to the vehicle being purchased. Once the customer answers those questions, a text message or e-mail report is sent to F&I so the menu can be customized specifically to the needs of each customer.

SmartPad is still in the early-adoption stage, but we are already seeing the benefits. There’s the dealer in Connecticut whose GAP penetration has jumped from 12 to 35 percent in his first month with SmartPad. But the real story here is not the numbers; it’s the impression the SmartPad has made on the dealer’s customers. It’s just difficult to quantify the “Wow” factor.

In our view, the only way menu selling can continue to work in the F&I office going forward is if we present it in a way that appeals to a broad range of consumers. And we think the SmartPad achieves that and more by streamlining the F&I process and delivering the “Wow” we need to deliver to our customers.

I also want to clear we’re not jumping on the Gen X and Y bandwagon with our solution. If you’ve ever looked closely at the thousands of people camped out at Apple and Best Buy stores to get the latest version of the iPad, you probably noticed the age range is broad. The one commonality among them is they want the latest and greatest tablet technology. My question to you is: Why should dealerships be any different?

Tablet-based technologies have taken off in virtually every vertical in every industry. And with so much of the population having adopted tablets for home or office use, they have become as familiar to auto buyers as their cell phone. That familiarity drives up their comfort level, and the more comfortable they are, the more they’ll buy.

The point is, technology is changing the way we do business, and we hope dealers will make an attempt to change as well.

Matt Nowicki serves as the vice president of retail software for Innovative Aftermarket Systems. E-mail him at matt.nowicki@bobit.com.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Digital

Mechanic's hand on digtial device screen next to a car
Digital•October 30, 2026

Fixed-Ops Automation Can Help Dealerships Stand Out

Technology turns everyday service repairs into lasting customer loyalty and dealer profitability.

LIght trails with nighttime cityscape in background
Digital•October 26, 2026

AI and the Auto Dealer

These are risks you can’t ignore as the technology becomes more and more of a presence in the auto retail environment.

Four people sitting at desk with various phones and laptops. Bar graph pictured on computer.
Digital•by Lauren Lawrence•October 26, 2026

Data Drives Success

Dealerships that make decisions based on data rather than gut instinct or experience have a leg up on their competitors, according to a recent survey.

Ad Loading...
Laptop computer on a desk with a notepad and pen next to it and a whiteboard in the background
Digital•by Rick McCormick•October 15, 2026

AI: Facilitator, Not Fixer, in F&I

The dealerships that thrive in the years ahead will be those that embrace technology while continuing to invest in the people who make customer interactions count.

Person at laptop with green-colored code on the screen
Digital•by Hannah Mitchell•October 5, 2026

Simple But Effective Hacking Surges

Data from the past year at U.S. auto dealerships finds that email and identity phishing are growing threat sources that can dispense with malware by exploiting trust.

Mechanic's hand working in car engine
Digital•September 10, 2026

The Future of Car Dealerships

Artificial intelligence is reshaping the service-drive experience and will help retailers stay competitive.

Ad Loading...
newspaper advertisement circled in pink, Turn Listings into Leads, F&I and Showroom
Digital•by Lauren Lawrence•August 5, 2026

Structure Leads to Optimized Auto Listings

As the average car-buying journey has shifted to a blend of digital and retail, a dealership’s vehicle listings must be optimized to answer shoppers’ questions clearly and accurately.

Photo of two businessmen shaking hands next to a white car in a showroom
Digital•by Hannah Mitchell•August 3, 2026

Real Intelligence

AI, though it presents many opportunities for productivity, efficiency and more, isn’t a one-for-one stand-in for people. It can augment human capital but not replace it altogether.

Photo of man's hand on laptop keyboard on a desk
Digital•by Staff•June 16, 2026

Zurich Launches Advisor IQ for F&I Manager Coaching

The new platform uses real transaction data and artificial intelligence-driven insights to help car dealerships improve consistency and performance.

Ad Loading...
Adapting to Digital For a convenient and trustworthy experience, F&I and Showroom
Digital•June 1, 2026

F&I in the Digital Age

Digital retailing has not made the F&I manager obsolete. If anything, it has revealed how valuable the role can become when technology is used correctly.